Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

add UCB bonus to planning progress explorer #1602

Merged
merged 8 commits into from
Dec 13, 2023
Merged

Conversation

tomsilver
Copy link
Collaborator

@tomsilver tomsilver commented Dec 13, 2023

Git commit hashes seen in results/:
cada9828a9876217ae926523440ae5d0697e0ef0


AGGREGATED DATA OVER SEEDS:
                                                         NUM_TRAIN_TASKS    NUM_SOLVED AVG_NUM_PREDS AVG_TEST_TIME AVG_NODES_CREATED     LEARNING_TIME   AVG_REF_COST  NUM_SEEDS
EXPERIMENT_ID                                      CYCLE                                                                                                                        
ball_and_cup_sticky_table-planning_progress_exp... 0        50.00 (0.00)   4.80 (1.60)  19.92 (1.95)   0.42 (0.01)      56.52 (5.82)       1.12 (0.08)    0.96 (0.50)          5
                                                   1        50.00 (0.00)   3.40 (1.36)  22.56 (2.33)   0.42 (0.02)      64.00 (6.24)     26.34 (48.34)    1.35 (0.54)          5
                                                   2        50.00 (0.00)   4.80 (1.17)  20.64 (2.45)   0.46 (0.05)      58.56 (6.56)    122.37 (83.28)    0.86 (0.26)          5
                                                   3        50.00 (0.00)   5.20 (1.33)  19.92 (3.09)   0.44 (0.01)      56.52 (8.46)    218.38 (62.96)    0.80 (0.26)          5
                                                   4        50.00 (0.00)   4.60 (2.65)  21.36 (6.32)   0.44 (0.00)     60.60 (17.81)    314.54 (68.15)    1.44 (1.29)          5
                                                   5        50.00 (0.00)   4.60 (1.85)  21.84 (3.90)   0.48 (0.06)     61.38 (10.42)    437.95 (64.60)    0.97 (0.32)          5
                                                   6        50.00 (0.00)   7.60 (2.06)  15.84 (3.51)   0.45 (0.02)     44.98 (10.40)    553.18 (46.26)    0.55 (0.22)          5
                                                   7        50.00 (0.00)   6.00 (1.90)  18.48 (3.09)   0.45 (0.03)      52.44 (8.62)    641.74 (36.77)    0.73 (0.31)          5
                                                   8        50.00 (0.00)   8.00 (1.41)  14.88 (2.23)   0.45 (0.03)      42.26 (5.82)    743.90 (59.61)    0.49 (0.10)          5
                                                   9        50.00 (0.00)   7.20 (3.71)  15.36 (4.45)   0.46 (0.04)      37.00 (2.99)    854.53 (56.49)    0.42 (0.05)          5
                                                   None     50.00 (0.00)   0.00 (0.00)  24.72 (0.59)     nan (nan)      35.96 (0.78)       0.32 (0.04)      nan (nan)          5
ball_and_cup_sticky_table-planning_progress_exp... 0        50.00 (0.00)   4.80 (1.60)  19.92 (1.95)   0.40 (0.00)      56.52 (5.82)       0.95 (0.04)    0.96 (0.50)          5
                                                   1        50.00 (0.00)   3.60 (1.20)  22.32 (2.23)   0.41 (0.03)      63.32 (6.00)     30.40 (56.85)    1.22 (0.44)          5
                                                   2        50.00 (0.00)   5.00 (0.89)  20.16 (1.59)   0.44 (0.02)      57.20 (4.11)    126.16 (90.69)    0.79 (0.15)          5
                                                   3        50.00 (0.00)   4.60 (1.85)  21.36 (3.97)   0.44 (0.00)     60.60 (10.80)    221.00 (60.04)    1.04 (0.53)          5
                                                   4        50.00 (0.00)   5.60 (2.80)  19.68 (6.81)   0.44 (0.01)     55.84 (19.35)    312.67 (65.97)    1.28 (1.34)          5
                                                   5        50.00 (0.00)   3.80 (2.14)  22.80 (4.02)   0.46 (0.05)     64.10 (10.91)    393.38 (65.72)    1.26 (0.47)          5
                                                   6        50.00 (0.00)   7.60 (1.62)  15.84 (2.56)   0.45 (0.02)      44.98 (7.68)    486.20 (82.55)    0.52 (0.13)          5
                                                   7        50.00 (0.00)   6.60 (2.06)  17.76 (3.34)   0.44 (0.01)      50.40 (9.15)    577.04 (99.61)    0.67 (0.32)          5
                                                   8        50.00 (0.00)   6.40 (3.38)  16.80 (4.55)   0.44 (0.00)      40.54 (5.25)   669.52 (114.24)    0.48 (0.09)          5
                                                   9        50.00 (0.00)   6.40 (3.61)  16.80 (4.62)   0.42 (0.02)      41.08 (8.97)   778.84 (133.32)    0.50 (0.16)          5
                                                   None     50.00 (0.00)   0.00 (0.00)  24.72 (0.59)     nan (nan)      35.96 (0.78)       0.28 (0.02)      nan (nan)          5
grid_row-planning_progress_explore_with_bonus      0        50.00 (0.00)   3.40 (1.36)  13.10 (0.92)   1.22 (0.26)     105.86 (0.55)      11.98 (0.40)  20.68 (15.27)          5
                                                   1        50.00 (0.00)   3.80 (2.14)  11.90 (1.91)   1.09 (0.21)     105.14 (1.14)    182.92 (92.85)  21.27 (16.07)          5
                                                   2        50.00 (0.00)   6.40 (3.14)   9.60 (3.20)   1.02 (0.14)     103.76 (1.92)    431.16 (78.59)  15.67 (17.67)          5
                                                   3        50.00 (0.00)   8.80 (0.75)   7.90 (0.86)   1.07 (0.06)     102.74 (0.52)    661.22 (98.08)    5.76 (0.49)          5
                                                   4        50.00 (0.00)   9.60 (0.80)   5.90 (1.80)   0.94 (0.11)     101.54 (1.08)    927.37 (84.06)    5.26 (0.52)          5
                                                   5        50.00 (0.00)  10.00 (0.00)   5.10 (0.20)   0.89 (0.02)     101.06 (0.12)   1164.63 (99.73)    5.00 (0.00)          5
                                                   6        50.00 (0.00)  10.00 (0.00)   5.30 (0.40)   0.92 (0.04)     101.18 (0.24)  1407.11 (128.59)    5.00 (0.00)          5
                                                   7        50.00 (0.00)  10.00 (0.00)   5.10 (0.20)   0.90 (0.04)     101.06 (0.12)  1688.86 (167.10)    5.00 (0.00)          5
                                                   8        50.00 (0.00)  10.00 (0.00)   5.30 (0.40)   0.93 (0.02)     101.18 (0.24)  1967.43 (174.90)    5.00 (0.00)          5
                                                   9        50.00 (0.00)  10.00 (0.00)   5.10 (0.20)   0.92 (0.04)     101.06 (0.12)  2240.40 (198.20)    5.00 (0.00)          5
                                                   None     50.00 (0.00)   0.00 (0.00)  25.00 (0.00)     nan (nan)     121.00 (0.00)       1.02 (0.03)      nan (nan)          5
grid_row-planning_progress_explore_without_bonus   0        50.00 (0.00)   3.40 (1.36)  13.10 (0.92)   1.15 (0.19)     105.86 (0.55)      11.88 (0.41)  20.68 (15.27)          5
                                                   1        50.00 (0.00)   3.80 (2.14)  11.90 (1.91)   1.05 (0.15)     105.14 (1.14)   186.81 (101.04)  21.27 (16.07)          5
                                                   2        50.00 (0.00)   6.40 (3.14)   9.60 (3.20)   1.01 (0.14)     103.76 (1.92)   418.81 (115.38)  15.67 (17.67)          5
                                                   3        50.00 (0.00)   8.80 (0.75)   7.90 (0.86)   1.04 (0.04)     102.74 (0.52)   638.03 (130.32)    5.76 (0.49)          5
                                                   4        50.00 (0.00)   9.60 (0.80)   5.90 (1.80)   0.94 (0.11)     101.54 (1.08)   881.55 (135.88)    5.26 (0.52)          5
                                                   5        50.00 (0.00)  10.00 (0.00)   5.10 (0.20)   0.90 (0.03)     101.06 (0.12)  1126.88 (146.11)    5.00 (0.00)          5
                                                   6        50.00 (0.00)  10.00 (0.00)   5.30 (0.40)   0.93 (0.04)     101.18 (0.24)  1391.76 (171.35)    5.00 (0.00)          5
                                                   7        50.00 (0.00)  10.00 (0.00)   5.10 (0.20)   0.91 (0.04)     101.06 (0.12)  1660.26 (202.93)    5.00 (0.00)          5
                                                   8        50.00 (0.00)  10.00 (0.00)   5.30 (0.40)   0.91 (0.04)     101.18 (0.24)  1939.40 (232.32)    5.00 (0.00)          5
                                                   9        50.00 (0.00)  10.00 (0.00)   5.10 (0.20)   0.90 (0.02)     101.06 (0.12)  2208.50 (246.59)    5.00 (0.00)          5
                                                   None     50.00 (0.00)   0.00 (0.00)  25.00 (0.00)     nan (nan)     121.00 (0.00)       0.98 (0.02)      nan (nan)          5

Copy link
Member

@NishanthJKumar NishanthJKumar left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

LGTM! Very nice!

@tomsilver tomsilver merged commit 33b1d21 into master Dec 13, 2023
6 checks passed
@tomsilver tomsilver deleted the add-ucb-to-main-explore branch December 13, 2023 18:28
@tomsilver
Copy link
Collaborator Author

It turns out that this PR was actually quite bad. Running 10 seeds is important!

AGGREGATED DATA OVER SEEDS:
                                                         NUM_TRAIN_TASKS   NUM_SOLVED AVG_NUM_PREDS AVG_TEST_TIME AVG_NODES_CREATED    LEARNING_TIME AVG_REF_COST  NUM_SEEDS
EXPERIMENT_ID                                      CYCLE                                                                                                                    
ball_and_cup_sticky_table-planning_progress_exp... 0        50.00 (0.00)  4.40 (1.56)  20.40 (2.08)   0.41 (0.01)      57.55 (5.99)      0.93 (0.04)  1.04 (0.49)         10
                                                   1        50.00 (0.00)  3.90 (2.02)  21.72 (2.81)   0.42 (0.01)     58.05 (10.88)    22.04 (41.00)  1.08 (0.52)         10
                                                   2        50.00 (0.00)  3.60 (1.80)  22.20 (2.70)   0.43 (0.01)     59.41 (10.86)    98.17 (70.42)  1.13 (0.49)         10
                                                   3        50.00 (0.00)  3.60 (2.37)  21.60 (3.39)   0.44 (0.01)     55.55 (11.88)   185.67 (81.74)  1.22 (1.07)         10
                                                   4        50.00 (0.00)  3.30 (2.65)  22.56 (4.94)   0.44 (0.01)     58.29 (16.57)  273.80 (108.55)  1.41 (1.06)         10
                                                   5        50.00 (0.00)  3.40 (2.69)  21.96 (3.40)   0.44 (0.01)     51.90 (14.06)  378.29 (133.83)  0.91 (0.31)         10
                                                   6        50.00 (0.00)  6.10 (2.81)  18.00 (3.94)   0.43 (0.01)     47.61 (10.62)  481.78 (165.32)  0.62 (0.22)         10
                                                   7        50.00 (0.00)  5.70 (2.65)  18.84 (3.72)   0.43 (0.02)     50.08 (10.83)  587.73 (165.65)  0.68 (0.26)         10
                                                   8        50.00 (0.00)  5.40 (3.72)  18.12 (4.34)   0.44 (0.02)      42.40 (6.62)  696.33 (188.65)  0.51 (0.10)         10
                                                   9        50.00 (0.00)  5.20 (4.31)  18.12 (4.99)   0.43 (0.02)      37.97 (4.44)  806.36 (207.60)  0.44 (0.05)         10
                                                   None     50.00 (0.00)  0.00 (0.00)  24.36 (0.55)     nan (nan)      35.50 (0.72)      0.29 (0.02)    nan (nan)         10
111

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants