Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

bip-340: reduce size of randomizers to 128 bit and provide argument #220

Closed
wants to merge 209 commits into from
Closed
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
209 commits
Select commit Hold shift + click to select a range
41efd13
added 'btc_hd_wallet' amongst implementations in bip32, bip39, bip85
Jun 25, 2020
3d29786
Require creator to initialize empty output fields
dr-orlovsky Sep 7, 2020
d509aa2
BIP 174: removing extra "fields" word
dr-orlovsky Sep 7, 2020
d353c54
Create portuguese.txt
sabotag3x Sep 1, 2020
eb57dc0
Change 'Client support' to 'Backwards compatibility'
Oct 5, 2020
dfa5042
Update bip-0085.mediawiki
hoganri Oct 17, 2020
9a119ce
BIP8: Make signalling during LOCKED_IN recommended rather than mandatory
ajtowns Oct 17, 2020
afe97b2
BIP8: allow some MUST_SIGNAL blocks to not signal
ajtowns Oct 17, 2020
77ed66a
Update bip-0085.mediawiki
hoganri Oct 22, 2020
d771818
Update formatting
hoganri Oct 22, 2020
8744a4d
fix typo
rikitau Oct 27, 2020
dfbbe04
Update bip-0039.mediawiki
meherett Nov 3, 2020
fcd5c5d
Update bip-0079.mediawiki
multisignature Nov 7, 2020
1a7eaa9
BIP-322: minor clarification
kallewoof Oct 30, 2020
c12af49
fixed typos
fametrano Nov 15, 2020
456c8c5
fixed input test case description as per output test case description
fametrano Nov 16, 2020
08844fd
BIP34 specifies it requires minimal encoding.
Greg-Griffith Nov 18, 2020
6fb34f2
Add BIP85-DRNG and other key derivations
ethankosakovsky Oct 30, 2020
cf32b7b
Say that public nonce is R and private nonce is s
OrfeasLitos Nov 30, 2020
23782b8
Remove the term "secret nonce", only refer to s
OrfeasLitos Nov 30, 2020
e963414
Add a link of another Rust implmentation of BIP-0039
koushiro Dec 17, 2020
518bb8b
README: Link BIP 2 for submissions
luke-jr Dec 18, 2020
cf0b529
Merge pull request #998 from sabotag3x/master
luke-jr Dec 20, 2020
a78b211
bip39: discourage from using localized wordlists
prusnak Dec 20, 2020
f778098
bip-0322: replace motivation, add myself to the "thanks to" list
apoelstra Dec 23, 2020
dbb81b3
bip-0322: move "legacy" section up, separate "proof of funds", summar…
apoelstra Dec 23, 2020
9e1beef
bip-0322: overhaul/rewrite verification rules
apoelstra Dec 23, 2020
c624414
bip-0322: remove the 'to_spend' transaction from serialization
apoelstra Dec 23, 2020
5f18700
p2p: Add disabletx message
sdaftuar Sep 3, 2020
644610f
bip-0141: clarify the sigop count calculation for CHECKMULTISIG
darosior Jan 10, 2021
6057fed
BIP 174: clarify format of proprietary extensions.
rustyrussell Jul 28, 2020
50fdf54
Reformat BIP 174
achow101 Jan 13, 2021
c099104
Explicitly specify PSBTv0
achow101 Jan 14, 2021
a4fb1b9
Specify procedure for new fields and versions
achow101 Jan 14, 2021
80df418
Include PSBT versions that can or must include field
achow101 Jan 14, 2021
c27d5e8
Mark BIP 174 as final
achow101 Jan 14, 2021
88fb205
Combine Appendix with field listing tables
achow101 Jan 14, 2021
794f20a
Add link to implementation
sdaftuar Jan 26, 2021
6128a7b
Add BIP 350 (bech32m)
sipa Dec 24, 2020
e192983
Update bip-0350.mediawiki
sipa Jan 29, 2021
d3874ff
Update bip-0350.mediawiki
sipa Jan 29, 2021
6446f2a
Update bip-0350.mediawiki
sipa Jan 29, 2021
e2cfb55
reject BIP175
omarshibli Jan 31, 2021
79cd91e
Merge pull request #1020 from ajtowns/202010-bip8-lockedin-rec
luke-jr Feb 2, 2021
0aa8c3a
Merge pull request #1021 from ajtowns/202010-bip8-mustsignal-to-thres…
luke-jr Feb 2, 2021
2fb8635
Merge pull request #1018 from hoganri/patch-2
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
e78a64f
Merge pull request #1028 from kallewoof/202010-signmsg2
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
c0be030
Merge pull request #1042 from OrfeasLitos/clarify-nonce
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
bcbc83f
Merge pull request #1026 from rikitau/bip85-fix-typo
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
f15b0d0
Merge pull request #1035 from multisignature/patch-1
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
ef89ae8
Merge pull request #1046 from luke-jr/readme_link_bip2
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
3b0662a
Merge pull request #1047 from prusnak/bip39-wordlist-warning
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
707dea4
Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin-pull/1040/head'
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
ee523cd
Merge pull request #1055 from achow101/reorganize-psbt
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
bc50a29
Merge pull request #1054 from darosior/bip141_multisig_sigops
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
f70132e
BIP 174: Revert title change to fit length limit
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
cf13cfa
Merge pull request #988 from dr-orlovsky/patch-1
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
942ef07
Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin-pull/1058/head'
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
9288ad7
Merge branch 'master' of github.com:bitcoin/bips
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
ab14d17
Merge pull request #1056 from sipa/bip-bech32m
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
53b79a6
Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin-pull/1048/head'
luke-jr Feb 3, 2021
c5b392c
Add back a few lost improvements
sipa Feb 4, 2021
30900e6
Merge pull request #1039 from Greg-Griffith/bip34-encoding-clarification
luke-jr Feb 4, 2021
518fd3f
Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin-pull/1036/head'
luke-jr Feb 4, 2021
63d2800
bip 8: simplify MUST_SIGNAL check
ajtowns Feb 4, 2021
b58dd7b
bip-0350: fix links for reference implementations
SomberNight Feb 5, 2021
ec213e1
Merge pull request #1063 from ajtowns/202102-bip8-simplify-mustsignal…
luke-jr Feb 8, 2021
1174b26
Merge pull request #1062 from sipa/202102_bip350_lost_improvements
luke-jr Feb 9, 2021
faeb2cc
Merge pull request #1066 from SomberNight/202002_bip350_fix_links
luke-jr Feb 9, 2021
cd1f225
BIP 155: Remove bitcoin.org link.
kiminuo Dec 15, 2020
4504be9
Merge #1044: BIP155: Remove external link
laanwj Feb 10, 2021
55a31eb
Add more language in hope of BIP number assignment
sdaftuar Feb 11, 2021
332b9a4
Note that tx messages are never allowed on disabletx links
sdaftuar Feb 12, 2021
31f61e7
Mention compatibility with bip 37
sdaftuar Feb 12, 2021
d2853bc
Assign BIP 338 for Disable transaction relay message
luke-jr Feb 12, 2021
bb9af2a
README: Fix colour for BIP 79
luke-jr Feb 12, 2021
19c429e
Merge BIP 338
luke-jr Feb 12, 2021
b3d224f
Specify BIP 370 PSBTv2
achow101 Jan 14, 2021
fbef072
Merge pull request #1029 from meherett/patch-1
luke-jr Feb 12, 2021
3a75853
Merge pull request #1045 from koushiro/koushiro/add-bip0039-rs
luke-jr Feb 12, 2021
febdf13
BIP 8: Make threshold a parameter
luke-jr Feb 17, 2021
6ea5857
BIP 8: Reduce threshold recommendation to 90%
luke-jr Feb 17, 2021
663efa5
BIP 8: Move recommendation for "name" to "Selection guidelines"
luke-jr Feb 17, 2021
1e25eb9
BIP 8: Advise not choosing a bit being used for other things
luke-jr Feb 17, 2021
72bf969
BIP 8: Avoid speculating precisely on how soon the economic majority …
luke-jr Feb 17, 2021
ca77342
bip8: remove recommendation to force activation after a year
darosior Feb 26, 2021
a118ef4
bip8: mention in intro the forced activation is optional
darosior Feb 26, 2021
5c6f023
Merge pull request #1070 from luke-jr/bip8_elaborate
luke-jr Feb 26, 2021
82000f6
Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin-pull/1073/head'
luke-jr Feb 26, 2021
48b3896
Merge branch 'bip8_threshold'
luke-jr Feb 26, 2021
c3f7e6f
Change `witness` to signature
sanket1729 Mar 2, 2021
6db1e16
Fixing Simple Signer Algorithm
dr-orlovsky Mar 2, 2021
333fc69
Merge pull request #1004 from prayank23/bip125-backwardscompatibility
luke-jr Mar 3, 2021
eaaf376
174: Change PSBT unknown fields test to use higher numbers
achow101 Mar 4, 2021
726cbf1
Fix typos in BIP 2
Matthiti Mar 6, 2021
3635e0e
fixed some typos and minor English mistakes
Mar 9, 2021
675c3a8
Create Multisig Derivation Standard.mediawiki
Mar 11, 2021
a067f9c
Formatting
Mar 11, 2021
ef3a16e
Update and rename Multisig Derivation Standard.mediawiki to Modern De…
Mar 12, 2021
c747ee9
Update Modern Derivation Standard.mediawiki
Mar 12, 2021
07d208e
BIP85: fixed test vector.
ethankosakovsky Mar 13, 2021
deba2a7
Clarify testnets
Mar 14, 2021
43b268c
Merge pull request #1079 from Matthiti/patch-1
luke-jr Mar 15, 2021
9bad9b5
Merge pull request #1085 from ethankosakovsky/patch-1
luke-jr Mar 15, 2021
36981bc
Merge pull request #1083 from 8go/patch-1
luke-jr Mar 15, 2021
4edd978
Fix Comments-URI for BIP 370
luke-jr Mar 15, 2021
d7cc276
Merge BIP 370
luke-jr Mar 15, 2021
cd3885c
Merge pull request #1078 from dr-orlovsky/patch-5
luke-jr Mar 15, 2021
4817829
BIP-85: Added Ian Coleman's Mnemonic Code Converter
Mar 15, 2021
8c346ca
Revert to multisig only
Mar 18, 2021
b4af07c
Add PSBT and ML reference
Mar 18, 2021
f4cea61
Clarifications
Mar 18, 2021
54fe116
Add minimum activation height to BIP 8
achow101 Mar 8, 2021
dacd6a2
Merge pull request #1080 from achow101/bip8-more-params
luke-jr Mar 20, 2021
73dce7a
BIP2 compliance. Add rationale, addresss discovery, etc.
Mar 22, 2021
ba9f775
Formatting
Mar 22, 2021
5161601
Merge pull request #2 from bitcoin/master
Mar 22, 2021
1361af2
Merge pull request #1 from Rspigler/Sane_Mulitisg_deriv
Mar 22, 2021
453d328
Grammar/formatting
Mar 22, 2021
f5a3140
BIP8: remove redundant and conflicting sentence from param selection
jonasnick Mar 16, 2021
e1def09
BIP8: fix typo: 2 retarget intervals are 4032 blocks.
jonasnick Mar 19, 2021
b1c2b5c
Fix errors
Mar 22, 2021
c7cd5e9
Formatting
Mar 22, 2021
a516c13
BIP341/342: document current deployment status
ajtowns Mar 25, 2021
1145b99
BIP 325: Remove empty section "Acknowledgement"
Mar 29, 2021
1f0b563
Merge pull request #1087 from jonasnick/bip8-nit
luke-jr Mar 29, 2021
f45d7c5
Update bip-0174.mediawiki
kiminuo Mar 31, 2021
89c7529
BIP: Bitcoin Secure Multisig Setup (BSMS)
hugohn Apr 5, 2021
0f95720
BIP341: bip9 speedy trial parameters
ajtowns Mar 24, 2021
d582d0b
BIP341: document simplified bip9 states
ajtowns Apr 8, 2021
754b77a
BIP 174: Add test vectors for additional unsigned tx serialization
achow101 Apr 8, 2021
ce5f89f
BIP341: add testnet3 parameters
ajtowns Apr 8, 2021
cda85c7
Minor: linking BIPs in BIP9
fresheneesz Apr 12, 2021
43b5f17
BIP 341/342: Add link to Bitcoin Core test vectors
jonasnick Apr 13, 2021
93d1b15
BIP341: add brackets to avoid ambiguity due to precendence rules arou…
ajtowns Apr 13, 2021
5933247
Changing BIP links in BIP9 to relative urls.
fresheneesz Apr 14, 2021
f31fa9c
clarify Signer definition and add reference links
hugohn Apr 16, 2021
f2e81c8
include and verify the wallet's first address in round 2
hugohn Apr 16, 2021
633dab3
move descriptor to the second line in the descriptor record
hugohn Apr 17, 2021
01e9ce9
update test vectors
hugohn Apr 17, 2021
17a5a85
introduce descriptor template
hugohn Apr 19, 2021
9771c5e
replace XPUBs with keys to be more generic
hugohn Apr 19, 2021
3eb481c
minor edit
hugohn Apr 19, 2021
d95aa33
Update Modern Hierarchy for Deterministic Multisignature Wallets.medi…
Apr 19, 2021
25bacdc
Update Modern Hierarchy for Deterministic Multisignature Wallets.medi…
Apr 19, 2021
f18ddfb
Update Modern Hierarchy for Deterministic Multisignature Wallets.medi…
Apr 19, 2021
ccc8af4
Address Discovery Fixes
Apr 21, 2021
833040d
Merge pull request #1074 from sanket1729/patch-1
luke-jr Apr 22, 2021
48cc3ae
Merge pull request #1086 from 8go/patch-2
luke-jr Apr 22, 2021
5935963
Merge pull request #1094 from kiminuo/patch-3
luke-jr Apr 22, 2021
375f11a
Merge pull request #1099 from achow101/more-psbt-tests
luke-jr Apr 22, 2021
b233501
Merge pull request #1103 from jonasnick/bip341-testvectors
luke-jr Apr 22, 2021
d4ed08f
Merge pull request #1102 from fresheneesz/fresheneesz-minor-patch-1
luke-jr Apr 22, 2021
b966bd3
Merge pull request #1093 from MarcoFalke/patch-2
luke-jr Apr 23, 2021
abbb76e
Minor edit
hugohn Apr 24, 2021
3ecad81
update test vectors
hugohn Apr 24, 2021
45bc31d
minor edit
hugohn Apr 25, 2021
de79a73
add a test vector for public keys
hugohn Apr 25, 2021
75bb056
minor edit
hugohn Apr 25, 2021
e82de1d
minor edit
hugohn Apr 25, 2021
cf00b45
upgrade EXTENDED mode to 128-bit
hugohn Apr 25, 2021
40b10c8
Merge pull request #1104 from ajtowns/202103-bip341-speedy-trial-mtp
luke-jr Apr 25, 2021
7ae9e02
Minor edits, + backwards compatibility
Apr 26, 2021
4794d70
Merge pull request #3 from bitcoin/master
Apr 26, 2021
653b965
Add BSMS reference and key origin info
Apr 26, 2021
3f050db
add Compatibility section
hugohn Apr 28, 2021
83e9b39
fix test vector
hugohn Apr 28, 2021
83aa047
update Compatibility section
hugohn May 5, 2021
0408b41
minor edit
hugohn May 5, 2021
f13cd8d
update Compatibility section
hugohn May 6, 2021
229a60b
update Compatibility section
hugohn May 8, 2021
37b55d2
BIP: Mandatory activation of taproot deployment
michaelfolkson May 9, 2021
47847fe
minor edit
hugohn May 11, 2021
349d2ee
updates data encoding/decoding examples due to bech32m/bech32
danpape Mar 18, 2021
b644e29
update BIP number and rename file
hugohn May 15, 2021
73e581c
BIP 129: Bitcoin Secure Multisig Setup (BSMS)
hugohn May 15, 2021
0e9aef5
Correct BIP number
hugohn May 15, 2021
76c103a
Fix email format
hugohn May 15, 2021
c9249b2
update URI
hugohn May 15, 2021
cd223ea
BIP 87 assigned
May 15, 2021
10e4bc6
Update README.mediawiki
May 15, 2021
7e10290
Rename BIP 87: Modern Hierarchy for Deterministic Multisignature Wall…
May 15, 2021
5bbfab9
Merge pull request #1097 from hugohn/bip-hugonguyen-bsms
luke-jr May 15, 2021
42d7ae8
Merge branch 'bitcoin:master' into v2_Multisig_deriv
May 15, 2021
9c40c18
Link to merged BSMS, update examples
May 15, 2021
7663693
Change name for CI
May 15, 2021
d502f68
Minor edits and links
May 15, 2021
2371906
Minor edit
May 15, 2021
2305c5b
Add BIP draft for BIP32 path templates
dgpv Oct 26, 2020
6ffc354
bip-path-templates: Change chars for ranges from "[]" to "{}"
dgpv May 11, 2021
c90c76b
bip-path-templates: describe Wildcard index range
dgpv May 11, 2021
25f8c3e
bip-path-templates: Add Compatibility section
dgpv May 11, 2021
3d9a359
BIP88: number assigned, rename file and update README
dgpv May 15, 2021
01679c8
BIP88: clarifications, mistype fixes
dgpv May 16, 2021
b628a13
BIP88: use <code> tags more, instead of double quotes
dgpv May 16, 2021
14f731e
BIP 343 assigned
michaelfolkson May 17, 2021
7bf9c1b
Update README
michaelfolkson May 17, 2021
abc113e
BIP88: Add definition for "length of the template", "length of the path"
dgpv May 17, 2021
255b5b6
BIP340: remove batch speedup graph and link to it instead
jonasnick May 17, 2021
868c4f8
Merge pull request #1025 from dgpv/bip-path-templates
luke-jr May 17, 2021
eb7ab7a
README: Fix colours for BIPs 87 & 90
luke-jr May 17, 2021
3893c2d
Merge BIP 87
luke-jr May 17, 2021
e7ee4fe
Fix formatting for BIP 343
luke-jr May 17, 2021
a099f43
Merge BIP 343
luke-jr May 17, 2021
40b6828
Merge pull request #1122 from jonasnick/bip340-remove-graph
luke-jr May 17, 2021
8b35221
Merge pull request #1121 from danpape/bip-0136-bech32m
luke-jr May 17, 2021
2349ee4
Merge remote-tracking branch 'origin-pull/935/head'
luke-jr May 18, 2021
6a5c99f
Merge branch 'master' of github.com:bitcoin/bips
luke-jr May 18, 2021
4e696d1
bip-340: reduce size of randomizers to 128 bit and provide argument
jonasnick May 22, 2021
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
61 changes: 55 additions & 6 deletions README.mediawiki
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,4 +1,4 @@
People wishing to submit BIPs, first should propose their idea or document to the [https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-dev [email protected]] mailing list. After discussion, please open a PR. After copy-editing and acceptance, it will be published here.
People wishing to submit BIPs, first should propose their idea or document to the [https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-dev [email protected]] mailing list (do <em>not</em> assign a number - read <a href="bip-0002.mediawiki">BIP 2</a> for the full process). After discussion, please open a PR. After copy-editing and acceptance, it will be published here.

We are fairly liberal with approving BIPs, and try not to be too involved in decision making on behalf of the community. The exception is in very rare cases of dispute resolution when a decision is contentious and cannot be agreed upon. In those cases, the conservative option will always be preferred.

Expand Down Expand Up @@ -392,7 +392,7 @@ Those proposing changes should consider that ultimately consent may rest with th
| Nicolas Dorier
| Standard
| Draft
|- style="background-color: #ffffcf"
|- style="background-color: #ffcfcf"
| [[bip-0079.mediawiki|79]]
| Applications
| Bustapay :: a practical coinjoin protocol
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -434,6 +434,20 @@ Those proposing changes should consider that ultimately consent may rest with th
| Ethan Kosakovsky
| Informational
| Draft
|- style="background-color: #ffffcf"
| [[bip-0087.mediawiki|87]]
| Applications
| Hierarchy for Deterministic Multisig Wallets
| Robert Spigler
| Standard
| Proposed
|- style="background-color: #ffffcf"
| [[bip-0088.mediawiki|88]]
| Applications
| Hierarchical Deterministic Path Templates
| Dmitry Petukhov
| Informational
| Proposed
|- style="background-color: #cfffcf"
| [[bip-0090.mediawiki|90]]
|
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -645,6 +659,13 @@ Those proposing changes should consider that ultimately consent may rest with th
| Standard
| Draft
|- style="background-color: #ffffcf"
| [[bip-0129.mediawiki|129]]
| Applications
| Bitcoin Secure Multisig Setup (BSMS)
| Hugo Nguyen, Peter Gray, Marko Bencun, Aaron Chen, Rodolfo Novak
| Standard
| Proposed
|- style="background-color: #ffffcf"
| [[bip-0130.mediawiki|130]]
| Peer Services
| sendheaders message
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -847,20 +868,20 @@ Those proposing changes should consider that ultimately consent may rest with th
| Pieter Wuille, Greg Maxwell
| Informational
| Final
|- style="background-color: #ffffcf"
|- style="background-color: #cfffcf"
| [[bip-0174.mediawiki|174]]
| Applications
| Partially Signed Bitcoin Transaction Format
| Andrew Chow
| Standard
| Proposed
|-
| Final
|- style="background-color: #ffcfcf"
| [[bip-0175.mediawiki|175]]
| Applications
| Pay to Contract Protocol
| Omar Shibli, Nicholas Gregory
| Informational
| Draft
| Rejected
|-
| [[bip-0176.mediawiki|176]]
|
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -953,6 +974,13 @@ Those proposing changes should consider that ultimately consent may rest with th
| Standard
| Draft
|-
| [[bip-0338.mediawiki|338]]
| Peer Services
| Disable transaction relay message
| Suhas Daftuar
| Standard
| Draft
|-
| [[bip-0339.mediawiki|339]]
| Peer Services
| WTXID-based transaction relay
Expand Down Expand Up @@ -980,6 +1008,27 @@ Those proposing changes should consider that ultimately consent may rest with th
| Pieter Wuille, Jonas Nick, Anthony Towns
| Standard
| Draft
|- style="background-color: #ffffcf"
| [[bip-0343.mediawiki|343]]
| Consensus (soft fork)
| Mandatory activation of taproot deployment
| Shinobius, Michael Folkson
| Standard
| Proposed
|-
| [[bip-0350.mediawiki|350]]
| Applications
| Bech32m format for v1+ witness addresses
| Pieter Wuille
| Standard
| Draft
|-
| [[bip-0370.mediawiki|370]]
| Applications
| PSBT Version 2
| Andrew Chow
| Standard
| Draft
|}

<!-- IMPORTANT! See the instructions at the top of this page, do NOT JUST add BIPs here! -->
4 changes: 2 additions & 2 deletions bip-0002.mediawiki
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -192,7 +192,7 @@ A BIP may only change status from Draft (or Rejected) to Proposed, when the auth

BIPs should be changed from Draft or Proposed status, to Rejected status, upon request by any person, if they have not made progress in three years. Such a BIP may be changed to Draft status if the champion provides revisions that meaningfully address public criticism of the proposal, or to Proposed status if it meets the criteria required as described in the previous paragraph.

An Proposed BIP may progress to Final only when specific criteria reflecting real-world adoption has occurred. This is different for each BIP depending on the nature of its proposed changes, which will be expanded on below. Evaluation of this status change should be objectively verifiable, and/or be discussed on the development mailing list.
A Proposed BIP may progress to Final only when specific criteria reflecting real-world adoption has occurred. This is different for each BIP depending on the nature of its proposed changes, which will be expanded on below. Evaluation of this status change should be objectively verifiable, and/or be discussed on the development mailing list.

When a Final BIP is no longer relevant, its status may be changed to Replaced or Obsolete (which is equivalent to Replaced). This change must also be objectively verifiable and/or discussed.

Expand Down Expand Up @@ -326,7 +326,7 @@ For example, a preamble might include the following License header:
In this case, the BIP text is fully licensed under both the OSI-approved BSD 2-clause license as well as the GNU All-Permissive License, and anyone may modify and redistribute the text provided they comply with the terms of *either* license. In other words, the license list is an "OR choice", not an "AND also" requirement.

It is also possible to license source code differently from the BIP text. A optional License-Code header is placed after the License header. Again, each license must be referenced by their respective abbreviation given below.
It is also possible to license source code differently from the BIP text. An optional License-Code header is placed after the License header. Again, each license must be referenced by their respective abbreviation given below.

For example, a preamble specifying the optional License-Code header might look like:

Expand Down
Loading