For dev dont process css #213
Conversation
WalkthroughThe changes in this pull request involve modifications to various layout files and configuration settings related to CSS and JavaScript resource management in a Hugo theme. Key updates include the addition of a new section in the Changes
Assessment against linked issues
Suggested reviewers
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? 🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
Documentation and Community
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 2
🧹 Outside diff range and nitpick comments (19)
themes/beaver/layouts/page/about.html (1)
14-15: Consider removing fingerprinting in the development environmentTo improve build performance during development, consider removing fingerprinting of CSS files. Fingerprinting is primarily beneficial in production for cache busting.
Apply this diff to remove fingerprinting in development:
-<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"> +<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ .RelPermalink }}">themes/beaver/layouts/page/index.html (2)
26-27: Consider removing fingerprinting in the development environmentOmitting fingerprinting of CSS files during development can speed up build times, as cache busting is typically only necessary in production.
Apply this diff to remove fingerprinting in development:
-<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"> +<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ .RelPermalink }}">
56-57: Consider removing fingerprinting in the development environmentTo enhance development efficiency, consider removing fingerprinting of JavaScript files during development. This can reduce build times and simplify debugging.
Apply this diff to remove fingerprinting in development:
-<script defer src="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"></script> +<script defer src="{{ .RelPermalink }}"></script>themes/beaver/layouts/partials/page/site-scripts.html (1)
6-8: Consider removing fingerprinting in the development environmentBy omitting fingerprinting of JavaScript files during development, you can improve build performance and streamline the development process.
Apply this diff to remove fingerprinting in development:
-<script defer src="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"></script> +<script defer src="{{ .RelPermalink }}"></script>README.md (1)
26-30: Enhance production mode documentationWhile the added command is helpful, consider providing more context about when and why developers might need to check styles in production mode.
Consider expanding the documentation like this:
## To check modified styles like in production run server command ```bash hugo server -e production
+Use this command when you need to:
+- Verify how optimized CSS will look in production
+- Debug CSS issues that only appear with processed styles
+- Test performance with concatenated and minified assets</blockquote></details> <details> <summary>themes/beaver/layouts/page/single.html (1)</summary><blockquote> `19-23`: **Consider adding a comment explaining the environment-based CSS handling** Adding a brief comment would help other developers understand the purpose of the conditional CSS processing. ```diff +{{/* Process CSS differently in development vs production for faster development iteration */}} {{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }}themes/beaver/layouts/_default/list.html (1)
18-25: Consider consistent handling of pagination CSSThe pagination CSS is always minified regardless of environment, which is inconsistent with the development mode optimization objective.
Consider moving pagination CSS into the main CSS slice for consistent handling:
-{{ $paginationCss := resources.Get "css/pagination.css" | minify | fingerprint }} -<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ $paginationCss.RelPermalink }}"> +{{- $CSS = $CSS | append (resources.Get "css/pagination.css") }}themes/beaver/layouts/blog/list.html (2)
19-27: Consider standardizing CSS handling across all templatesThis template demonstrates the best practices for CSS handling:
- Includes all CSS files in the main slice
- Uses proper HTML attributes
- Maintains consistent indentation
Consider applying these patterns across all templates for consistency.
Example standardization for link tags:
-<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ $CSS.RelPermalink }}" media='all' /> +<link href="{{ $CSS.RelPermalink }}" media="all" rel="stylesheet" />
28-28: Remove unnecessary blank linesThere are multiple consecutive blank lines that can be reduced to one.
themes/beaver/layouts/partials/page/testimonials.html (2)
1-9: Enhance resource loading performance in production.While the environment-based CSS loading is implemented correctly, the production mode could benefit from additional performance optimizations.
Apply this diff to improve resource loading:
{{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }} <link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ ($nonCriticalCSS | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"> {{ else }} {{- $nonCriticalCSS = $nonCriticalCSS | postCSS | minify | fingerprint | resources.PostProcess}} -<link fetchpriority="low" rel="preload" href="{{ $nonCriticalCSS.RelPermalink }}" as="style" onload="this.onload=null;this.rel='stylesheet'"> +<link fetchpriority="low" rel="preload" href="{{ $nonCriticalCSS.RelPermalink }}" as="style" + onload="this.onload=null;this.rel='stylesheet'" crossorigin="anonymous"> <noscript><link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ $nonCriticalCSS.RelPermalink }}"></noscript> {{ end }}
Line range hint
43-54: Consider moving inline styles to external CSS files.While not directly related to the PR objective, the template contains multiple inline styles and a
<style>block. Moving these to external CSS files would:
- Improve maintainability
- Better separate concerns
- Allow for proper CSS optimization in production
Consider moving these styles to a new file
assets/css/testimonials.cssand including it in the CSS bundle.Also applies to: 90-93, 96-96, 100-100, 104-104, 108-108, 112-112
themes/beaver/layouts/page/use-cases.html (2)
6-16: Add comments explaining the purpose of each CSS file.While the multi-line format improves readability, adding comments would help future maintainers understand the purpose and dependencies of each CSS file.
Apply this diff to improve documentation:
{{- $CSS := slice + # Layout styles (resources.Get "css/3021-layout.css") (resources.Get "css/bf72bba397177a0376baed325bffdc75-layout-bundle.css") + # Dynamic styles $dynamicCSS586 (resources.Get "css/586.css") + # Core styles (resources.Get "css/base-4.min.css") (resources.Get "css/style.css") (resources.Get "css/skin-65eda28877e04.css") + # Feature-specific styles (resources.Get "css/technologies.css") (resources.Get "css/footer.css") + # Page-specific styles $dynamicCSSUseCases }}
31-42: Add error handling for JS resource loading.While the environment-based JS handling is implemented correctly, it lacks error handling for missing resources.
Consider wrapping the resource loading in a try-catch block:
{{ $tabs := slice +(resources.Get "js/tabs.js" | default (errorf "Required resource js/tabs.js not found")) -resources.Get "js/tabs.js" }} {{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }} {{- range $tabs }} <script defer src="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"></script> {{ end }} {{ else }} {{- $tabs = $tabs | resources.Concat "js/_tabs.js" | js.Build (dict "minify" true) | minify | fingerprint | resources.PostProcess }} <script defer src="{{ $tabs.RelPermalink }}"></script> {{ end }}themes/beaver/layouts/page/clients.html (1)
17-22: Consider adding media attribute in development mode.The
media='all'attribute is only present in production mode. For consistency, consider adding it to development mode links as well.-<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"> +<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}" media='all'>themes/beaver/layouts/page/contact-us.html (1)
15-22: Consider error handling for CSS resource loading.While the implementation is correct, consider adding error handling for CSS resource loading failures.
{{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }} {{- range $CSS }} +{{- if . }} <link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"> +{{- else }} +{{- warnf "Failed to load CSS resource" }} +{{- end }} {{ end }}themes/beaver/layouts/page/free-consultation.html (1)
4-21: LGTM: Implementation aligns with PR objectives.The changes successfully implement different CSS handling for development and production environments, meeting the goal of skipping CSS processing during development.
Consider creating a shared partial template for CSS handling to:
- Reduce code duplication across templates
- Centralize error handling
- Ensure consistent attributes
Example structure:
{{/* layouts/partials/css-handler.html */}} {{ define "css-handler" }} {{ $css := .css }} {{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }} {{- range $css }} {{- if . }} <link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}" media='all'> {{- else }} {{- warnf "Failed to load CSS resource" }} {{- end }} {{ end }} {{ else }} {{- $css = $css | resources.Concat .output | postCSS | minify | fingerprint | resources.PostProcess }} <link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ $css.RelPermalink }}" media='all' /> {{ end }} {{ end }}themes/beaver/layouts/clients/single.html (1)
15-22: Consider adding error handling for missing CSS filesWhile the conditional loading logic effectively implements the development mode requirements, consider adding error handling for missing CSS files to prevent runtime issues.
{{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }} {{- range $CSS }} + {{ if . }} <link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"> + {{ else }} + {{ warnf "Missing CSS file in development mode" }} + {{ end }} {{ end }}themes/beaver/layouts/use-cases/single.html (1)
5-24: Fix inconsistent formatting in CSS resource handlingThe formatting (newlines and indentation) differs from other templates. Let's maintain consistency across the codebase.
-{{ $CSS := slice -(resources.Get "css/3027-layout.css") -(resources.Get "css/bf72bba397177a0376baed325bffdc75-layout-bundle.css") -$dynamicCSS586 -(resources.Get "css/586.css") -(resources.Get "css/base-4.min.css") -(resources.Get "css/style.css") -(resources.Get "css/skin-65eda28877e04.css") -(resources.Get "css/footer.css") -}} +{{- $CSS := slice + (resources.Get "css/3027-layout.css") + (resources.Get "css/bf72bba397177a0376baed325bffdc75-layout-bundle.css") + $dynamicCSS586 + (resources.Get "css/586.css") + (resources.Get "css/base-4.min.css") + (resources.Get "css/style.css") + (resources.Get "css/skin-65eda28877e04.css") + (resources.Get "css/footer.css") +}} -{{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }} +{{- if hugo.IsDevelopment }}themes/beaver/layouts/services/single.html (1)
4-22: Consider optimizing development mode performanceWhile the conditional handling of CSS resources aligns well with the PR objectives, fingerprinting in development mode might be unnecessary and could impact reload times.
Consider this optimization:
{{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }} {{- range $CSS }} -<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"> +<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ .RelPermalink }}"> {{ end }}
📜 Review details
Configuration used: .coderabbit.yaml
Review profile: CHILL
📒 Files selected for processing (22)
README.md(2 hunks)postcss.config.js(1 hunks)themes/beaver/assets/css/single-post.css(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/404.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/_default/list.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/_default/single.html(3 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/blog/list.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/careers/single.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/clients/single.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/page/about.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/page/careers.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/page/clients.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/page/contact-us.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/page/free-consultation.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/page/index.html(2 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/page/services.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/page/single.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/page/use-cases.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/partials/page/site-scripts.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/partials/page/testimonials.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/services/single.html(1 hunks)themes/beaver/layouts/use-cases/single.html(1 hunks)
🔇 Additional comments (14)
postcss.config.js (1)
22-23: LGTM: Safelist addition for comment-link class
The addition of "comment-link" to the safelist ensures the class won't be purged during CSS optimization, which is necessary for the new comment link feature.
themes/beaver/layouts/_default/single.html (3)
Line range hint 6-15: LGTM: CSS resources organization
The CSS resources are well-organized and include all necessary stylesheets, with the new footer.css addition properly integrated.
18-25: Well-implemented environment-specific CSS handling
The conditional CSS processing aligns perfectly with the PR objective:
- Development: Individual CSS files for faster builds
- Production: Optimized, concatenated CSS
57-59: LGTM: Secure implementation of comment link
The comment link implementation includes proper security attributes (rel="nofollow noopener").
themes/beaver/layouts/page/single.html (2)
5-13: LGTM: Well-structured CSS resource declaration
The multi-line slice format improves readability and maintainability of CSS resource declarations.
15-22: LGTM: Development mode optimization implemented correctly
The development mode implementation correctly serves individual CSS files with fingerprinting, which aligns with the PR objective of faster development iteration by skipping CSS optimization.
themes/beaver/layouts/404.html (1)
4-20: LGTM! Environment-based CSS handling is properly implemented.
The implementation correctly differentiates between development and production environments, aligning with the PR objective to prevent CSS optimization during development.
themes/beaver/layouts/page/clients.html (1)
5-14: LGTM: CSS resources are well-organized.
The multi-line format improves readability and maintainability.
themes/beaver/layouts/page/contact-us.html (1)
5-13: LGTM: CSS resource management is consistent.
The implementation follows the same pattern as other templates, maintaining consistency across the codebase.
themes/beaver/layouts/clients/single.html (1)
5-13: LGTM: Well-structured CSS resource collection
The CSS resources are clearly organized and properly managed using Hugo's resource pipeline. The multi-line format improves readability and maintainability.
themes/beaver/layouts/page/services.html (2)
6-24: Similar fingerprinting optimization applies here
The same development mode optimization suggested in the services/single.html template applies here.
35-44: LGTM! Proper handling of JS resources
The conditional processing of JavaScript resources correctly implements the PR objective of avoiding optimization in development mode while maintaining production optimizations.
themes/beaver/layouts/page/careers.html (2)
5-22: Same fingerprinting optimization applies here
The same development mode optimization suggested for other templates applies here.
Line range hint 589-597: LGTM! Icon swap functions are correct
The JavaScript functions for icon swapping are properly implemented and unaffected by the development/production mode changes.
| } | ||
|
|
||
| .comment-link {text-decoration: none!important; margin-top: 2rem} |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Avoid using !important in CSS unless necessary
Using !important can make CSS harder to maintain and override. If not essential, consider removing it to improve code maintainability.
Apply this diff to remove !important:
-.comment-link {text-decoration: none!important; margin-top: 2rem}
+.comment-link {text-decoration: none; margin-top: 2rem}📝 Committable suggestion
‼️ IMPORTANT
Carefully review the code before committing. Ensure that it accurately replaces the highlighted code, contains no missing lines, and has no issues with indentation. Thoroughly test & benchmark the code to ensure it meets the requirements.
| .comment-link {text-decoration: none!important; margin-top: 2rem} | |
| .comment-link {text-decoration: none; margin-top: 2rem} |
| {{- $CSS := slice | ||
| (resources.Get "css/3114-layout.css") | ||
| (resources.Get "css/e966db44b09892b8d7d492247c67e86c-layout-bundle.css") | ||
| $dynamicCSS586 (resources.Get "css/586.css") | ||
| (resources.Get "css/homepage.css") | ||
| (resources.Get "css/base-4.min.css") | ||
| (resources.Get "css/style.css") | ||
| (resources.Get "css/skin-65eda28877e04.css") | ||
| (resources.Get "css/footer.css") }} | ||
|
|
||
| {{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }} | ||
| {{- range $CSS }} | ||
| <link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}"> | ||
| {{ end }} | ||
| {{ else }} | ||
| {{- $CSS = $CSS | resources.Concat "css/single/careers.css" | postCSS | minify | fingerprint | resources.PostProcess}} | ||
| <link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ $CSS.RelPermalink }}" media='all' /> | ||
| {{ end }} |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
🛠️ Refactor suggestion
Consider extracting common CSS handling logic into a partial template
The CSS resource handling logic is duplicated across multiple templates. Consider creating a shared partial template to improve maintainability.
Create a new partial template themes/beaver/layouts/partials/css/resource-handler.html:
{{- define "css-resource-handler" }}
{{ $CSS := .css_files }}
{{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }}
{{- range $CSS }}
<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}">
{{ end }}
{{ else }}
{{- $CSS = $CSS | resources.Concat .output_path | postCSS | minify | fingerprint | resources.PostProcess}}
<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ $CSS.RelPermalink }}" media='all' />
{{ end }}
{{ end }}Then use it in the templates:
-{{ if hugo.IsDevelopment }}
-{{- range $CSS }}
-<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ (. | fingerprint).RelPermalink }}">
-{{ end }}
-{{ else }}
-{{- $CSS = $CSS | resources.Concat "css/single/careers.css" | postCSS | minify | fingerprint | resources.PostProcess}}
-<link rel="stylesheet" href="{{ $CSS.RelPermalink }}" media='all' />
-{{ end }}
+{{ partial "css/resource-handler.html" (dict "css_files" $CSS "output_path" "css/single/careers.css") }}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Seems like the humans are having a chat. I'll hop back into my burrow for now. If you need me again, just tag @coderabbitai in a new comment, and I'll come hopping out!
Closes #212
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
.comment-linkfor better styling.Bug Fixes
Documentation
Style