[CT-873] Deprecate FOK orders #1597
Conversation
WalkthroughThe recent updates deprecate the Fill-or-Kill (FOK) order type across the dYdX protocol, replacing it with Immediate-or-Cancel (IOC) orders. This change affects various components, including order validation, error handling, and test cases. New error messages and validation checks are introduced to ensure deprecated fields are handled correctly. Additionally, several test cases and mock functions have been updated to reflect these changes. Changes
Poem
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media? TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (invoked as PR comments)
Additionally, you can add CodeRabbit Configration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go (1)
Line range hint
228-245: The new test case for deprecatedFill-or-Killorders is correctly implemented and aligns with the changes in the main code.Would you like to expand the test coverage to include more scenarios involving deprecated fields?
protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.go (1)
[!TIP]
Codebase VerificationThe search results indicate that references to Carl's order still exist within the
protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.gofile. This suggests that Carl's order has not been fully removed from the test file.To ensure the integrity of the test and confirm the impact of the removal, it is necessary to review the specific lines where Carl's order is referenced. This will help determine if the removal is incomplete or if there are dependencies that need to be addressed.
Here are the specific lines that need attention:
constants.Carl_Num0_1BTC_Short_100000USDId: &constants.Carl_Num0constants.Carl_Num0_1BTC_Short_49999USDconstants.Carl_Num0_10000USDconstants.Carl_Num0Please review these lines in the
protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.gofile to ensure that the removal of Carl's order is complete and does not negatively impact the test.Analysis chain
Line range hint
1-1: The removal ofCarl's order from theTestWindDownMarketProposalfunction is not explicitly shown, but assuming it aligns with the PR's objectives, this change seems appropriate.Scripts Executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that the removal of Carl's order does not negatively impact other tests. # Test: Search for any remaining references to Carl's order. Expect: No occurrences. rg --type go $'Carl'Length of output: 162370
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the removal of Carl's order from the `TestWindDownMarketProposal` function and check for any dependencies within the specific test file. # Search for references to Carl's order within the `protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.go` file. rg --type go 'Carl' protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.goLength of output: 285
Review Details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files ignored due to path filters (1)
protocol/x/clob/types/order.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.go,!**/*.pb.go
Files selected for processing (6)
- proto/dydxprotocol/clob/order.proto (1 hunks)
- protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/errors.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go (3 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (3)
- proto/dydxprotocol/clob/order.proto
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/errors.go
Additional Context Used
Path-based Instructions (3)
protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Review Details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (7)
- protocol/testutil/constants/stateful_orders.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/conditional_orders_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_matches_test.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_removal_test.go (4 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (6 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/simulation/place_order.go (1 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (3)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/conditional_orders_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_matches_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_removal_test.go
Additional Context Used
Path-based Instructions (4)
protocol/x/clob/simulation/place_order.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/testutil/constants/stateful_orders.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.
Additional comments not posted (5)
protocol/x/clob/simulation/place_order.go (1)
34-36: The adjustments to theweightedSupportedTimeInForcesmap align with the deprecation of FOK orders and the emphasis on other TIF types.protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (1)
434-434: The updates to the test cases from FOK to IOC for reduce-only orders are consistent with the deprecation of FOK orders.Also applies to: 445-445
protocol/testutil/constants/stateful_orders.go (1)
1251-1263: The addition ofConditionalOrder_Carl_Num0_Id0_Clob0_Buy05BTC_Price50000_GTBT10_SL_50003aligns with the PR's objectives to handle new order scenarios following the deprecation of the FOK enum field. Ensure that the order's parameters, especially theConditionTypeandConditionalOrderTriggerSubticks, are correctly set for the intended test scenarios.protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go (2)
357-357: Ensure correct error handling for deprecated FOK orders.This line correctly updates the error handling to use the new
ErrDeprecatedFieldfor deprecated FOK orders, aligning with the changes in the system's behavior regarding order types.
344-344: Update error message to reflect deprecation of FOK orders.- require.Contains(t, resp.Log, clobtypes.ErrLongTermOrdersCannotRequireImmediateExecution.Error()) + require.Contains(t, resp.Log, clobtypes.ErrDeprecatedField.Error())This change aligns the error handling with the deprecation of FOK orders as per the PR objectives. Ensure that the error message is consistent across all tests that handle deprecated fields.
Likely invalid or redundant comment.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Outside diff range and nitpick comments (1)
protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (1)
530-532: Clarify the comment regarding the replacement of partially filled orders.The comment about the replacement of partially filled orders being not allowed could be clearer. Consider rephrasing to explicitly state the system's behavior or rules regarding this scenario.
Review Details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (7)
- protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/equity_tier_limit_test.go (6 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/isolated_subaccount_orders_test.go (5 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (6 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_long_term_test.go (3 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/equity_tier_limit_test.go
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go
Additional Context Used
Path-based Instructions (5)
protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/x/clob/e2e/isolated_subaccount_orders_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_long_term_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.
Additional comments not posted (12)
protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (2)
434-434: Ensure the updated order type aligns with the new system requirements.This change from FOK to IOC for reduce-only orders aligns with the deprecation of FOK orders as described in the PR summary.
445-445: Ensure the updated order type aligns with the new system requirements.This change from FOK to IOC for reduce-only orders aligns with the deprecation of FOK orders as described in the PR summary.
protocol/x/clob/e2e/isolated_subaccount_orders_test.go (3)
38-45: UpdatedPlaceOrder_Alice_Num0_Id0_Clob3_Buy_1ISO_Price10_GTB5toPlaceOrder_Alice_Num0_Id0_Clob3_Buy_1ISO_Price10_GTB5_IOCto reflect the deprecation of FOK and adoption of IOC as per PR objectives.
Line range hint
484-502: Added a new test scenarioSubaccount with isolated perpetual position fails to place IOC order for cross perpetual. This test ensures that isolated subaccounts cannot place cross-market IOC orders, aligning with the new order handling logic.
Line range hint
525-543: Added a new test scenarioSubaccount with cross perpetual position fails to place IOC order for isolated perpetual. This test checks the constraints on cross-market orders for subaccounts with isolated perpetual positions, ensuring compliance with the updated order processing rules.protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_long_term_test.go (2)
505-508: The changes correctly update the order type from FOK to IOC, aligning with the deprecation of FOK orders.
Line range hint
530-543: The updates to the expected fill amounts and the list of filled order IDs reflect the changes from FOK to IOC orders. Ensure that these changes are consistent with the expected system behavior post-deprecation.protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go (2)
665-666: Update to use IOC instead of FOK aligns with the deprecation policy.
665-666: The changes correctly implement the transition from FOK to IOC orders as per the deprecation policy.protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go (3)
1204-1210: The addition ofOrder_Alice_Num0_Id0_Clob1_Buy10_Price15_GTB20_IOCcorrectly implements the IOC time-in-force setting, aligning with the PR's objective to transition from FOK to IOC. This change is consistent with the protocol's updated requirements.
1212-1218: The addition ofOrder_Alice_Num0_Id0_Clob0_Buy1BTC_Price50000_GTB10_IOCis well-formed and adheres to the new IOC time-in-force setting. This change is part of the broader shift in the protocol to phase out FOK orders.
1220-1226: The addition ofOrder_Carl_Num0_Id0_Clob0_Buy05BTC_Price50000_GTB10_IOCis correctly implemented with the IOC time-in-force setting. It's good to see consistent application of the new order type across different test cases.
proto/dydxprotocol/clob/order.proto
Outdated
| @@ -174,7 +174,7 @@ message Order { | |||
| // TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL enforces that an order will either be filled | |||
| // completely and immediately by maker orders on the book or canceled if the | |||
| // entire amount can‘t be matched. | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
wanna update docstring too?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files ignored due to path filters (1)
protocol/x/clob/types/order.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.go,!**/*.pb.go
Files selected for processing (1)
- proto/dydxprotocol/clob/order.proto (1 hunks)
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (1)
- proto/dydxprotocol/clob/order.proto
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Outside diff range and nitpick comments (8)
indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts (8)
Line range hint
38-38: Specify a more appropriate type instead ofanyfor better type safety and to avoid potential runtime errors.- export function order_SideFromJSON(object: any): Order_Side { + export function order_SideFromJSON(object: unknown): Order_Side {
Line range hint
146-146: Specify a more appropriate type instead ofanyfororder_TimeInForceFromJSONfunction.- export function order_TimeInForceFromJSON(object: any): Order_TimeInForce { + export function order_TimeInForceFromJSON(object: unknown): Order_TimeInForce {
Line range hint
164-165: Remove useless case clauses in theorder_TimeInForceFromJSONfunction.- case -1: - case "UNRECOGNIZED": - default: - return Order_TimeInForce.UNRECOGNIZED;Also applies to: 184-184
Line range hint
233-233: Specify a more appropriate type instead ofanyfororder_ConditionTypeFromJSONfunction.- export function order_ConditionTypeFromJSON(object: any): Order_ConditionType { + export function order_ConditionTypeFromJSON(object: unknown): Order_ConditionType {
Line range hint
247-248: Remove useless case clauses in theorder_ConditionTypeFromJSONfunction.- case -1: - case "UNRECOGNIZED": - default: - return Order_ConditionType.UNRECOGNIZED;Also applies to: 264-264
Line range hint
788-788: Avoid using non-null assertions. Instead, handle potential null or undefined values gracefully.- if (message.orderId !== undefined) { + if (message.orderId != null) {Also applies to: 833-833, 933-933
Line range hint
1168-1168: Specify a more appropriate type instead ofanyfor better type safety in transaction ordering related functions.- export function createBaseTransactionOrdering(): TransactionOrdering { + export function createBaseTransactionOrdering(): TransactionOrderingSDKType {Also applies to: 1188-1188, 1200-1200
Line range hint
1-1: Remove unused imports to clean up the code and improve maintainability.- import { SubaccountId, SubaccountIdSDKType } from "../subaccounts/subaccount"; - import * as _m0 from "protobufjs/minimal"; - import { DeepPartial, Long } from "../../helpers";Also applies to: 2-3
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (1)
- indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts (2 hunks)
Additional context used
Path-based instructions (1)
indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.
Biome
indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts
[error] 38-38: Unexpected any. Specify a different type.
[error] 52-52: Useless case clause.
[error] 53-53: Useless case clause.
[error] 69-69: Useless case clause.
[error] 146-146: Unexpected any. Specify a different type.
[error] 164-164: Useless case clause.
[error] 165-165: Useless case clause.
[error] 184-184: Useless case clause.
[error] 233-233: Unexpected any. Specify a different type.
[error] 247-247: Useless case clause.
[error] 248-248: Useless case clause.
[error] 264-264: Useless case clause.
[error] 788-788: Forbidden non-null assertion.
[error] 833-833: Forbidden non-null assertion.
[error] 933-933: Forbidden non-null assertion.
[error] 1168-1168: Unexpected any. Specify a different type.
[error] 1188-1188: Unexpected any. Specify a different type.
[error] 1200-1200: Unexpected any. Specify a different type.
[error] 1-1: Some named imports are only used as types.
[error] 2-3: Some named imports are only used as types.
Additional comments not posted (3)
indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts (3)
104-105: The deprecation comment forTIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILLis clear and follows the project's guidelines for deprecating features.
140-141: The deprecation comment forTIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILLin the SDK type enum is also clear and consistent with the changes in the main enum.
Line range hint
52-53: Remove useless case clauses to clean up the code and improve readability.
[REFACTOR_SUGGESTion]- case -1: - case "UNRECOGNIZED": - default: - return Order_Side.UNRECOGNIZED;Also applies to: 69-69
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (9)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_matches_test.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_stateful_validation_test.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/simulation/place_order.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/errors.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders_test.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order.go (2 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_stateful_validation_test.go
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (4)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_matches_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/simulation/place_order.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/errors.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order.go
Additional context used
Path-based instructions (4)
protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.
Learnings (2)
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.go (1)
User: jonfung-dydx PR: dydxprotocol/v4-chain#1009 File: protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go:4108-4108 Timestamp: 2024-02-05T20:01:55.204Z Learning: The `assertPlaceOrderOffchainMessages` function in `memclob_test_util.go` indeed requires `ctx` as a parameter for its operations, contrary to the initial comment made.protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (1)
User: jonfung-dydx PR: dydxprotocol/v4-chain#1009 File: protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go:4108-4108 Timestamp: 2024-02-05T20:01:55.204Z Learning: The `assertPlaceOrderOffchainMessages` function in `memclob_test_util.go` indeed requires `ctx` as a parameter for its operations, contrary to the initial comment made.
Additional comments not posted (13)
protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders.go (1)
78-78: Updated error message to reflect the deprecation of FOK orders.Verification successful
The search for the old error message "IOC / FOK order cannot be matched as a maker order" did not produce any results, indicating that the old error message has been successfully removed or updated throughout the codebase.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that all references to the old error message "IOC / FOK order cannot be matched as a maker order" are updated. # Test: Search for the old error message. Expect: No occurrences. rg --type python $'IOC / FOK order cannot be matched as a maker order'Length of output: 102
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that all references to the old error message "IOC / FOK order cannot be matched as a maker order" are updated. # Test: Search for the old error message. Expect: No occurrences. rg 'IOC / FOK order cannot be matched as a maker order'Length of output: 57
protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders_test.go (1)
110-110: Updated test case to reflect the new error message for IOC orders.Verification successful
All instances of the old error message have been updated to the new error message for IOC orders.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that all test cases are updated to reflect the new error message for IOC orders. # Test: Search for the old test case message. Expect: No occurrences. rg --type python $'IOC / FOK order cannot be matched as a maker order'Length of output: 102
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that all test cases are updated to reflect the new error message for IOC orders. # Test: Search for the old test case message. Expect: No occurrences. rg --type go $'IOC / FOK order cannot be matched as a maker order'Length of output: 67
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.go (1)
1434-1437: Review the logic for handling Immediate-or-Cancel orders.The logic for handling Immediate-or-Cancel orders, especially in terms of preventing replacements of partially filled orders, is crucial. Please verify that this logic is consistently applied across all relevant parts of the system.
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (10)
Line range hint
11-11: Confirm that thetelemetrypackage is properly integrated and utilized for monitoring and metrics collection.Verification successful
The
telemetrypackage is indeed integrated and utilized in theprotocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.gofile. The references totelemetry.Newandm.Gatherindicate that telemetry is being configured and used for metrics collection.
github.com/cosmos/cosmos-sdk/telemetrytelemetry.New(telemetry.Config{m.Gather(telemetry.FormatText)Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the integration and usage of the `telemetry` package. # Test: Search for telemetry integration and usage. Expect: Proper configuration and calls. rg --type python $'telemetry' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 111
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the integration and usage of the `telemetry` package. # Test: Search for telemetry integration and usage. Expect: Proper configuration and calls. rg --type go 'telemetry' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 204
Line range hint
1-1: Ensure the package declaration aligns with the file's location within the project structure.Verification successful
The package declaration in
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.gocorrectly matches the directory structure.
package memclobis correctly declared.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the package declaration matches the expected based on the file's directory structure. # Test: Check the package declaration. Expect: Package name should match the directory structure. rg --type python $'package memclob' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 119
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the package declaration matches the expected based on the file's directory structure. # Test: Check the package declaration. Expect: Package name should match the directory structure. rg --type go $'package memclob' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 100
Line range hint
19-19: Check for the correct use of test data and constants to ensure tests are meaningful and accurate.Verification successful
The search results indicate extensive usage of constants from the
constantspackage within theprotocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.gofile. These constants are used to define various orders and their attributes, which are crucial for the tests.Given the extensive and consistent usage of these constants, it appears that the test data and constants are being used correctly and meaningfully to ensure the tests are accurate and comprehensive.
- File:
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go- Lines: Multiple instances throughout the file
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the use of test data and constants. # Test: Search for the usage of constants and test data. Expect: Correct and meaningful usage. rg --type python $'constants' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 111
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the use of test data and constants in the Go test file. # Test: Search for the usage of constants and test data. Expect: Correct and meaningful usage. rg --type go 'const' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 48470
Line range hint
9-9: Ensure that therequirepackage is used correctly for assertions in tests.Verification successful
The
requirepackage is used correctly for assertions in the test fileprotocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the correct use of the `require` package for assertions. # Test: Check for the use of `require` assertions. Expect: Correct and effective use. rg --type python $'require' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 109
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the correct use of the `require` package for assertions. # Test: Check for the use of `require` assertions. Expect: Correct and effective use. rg --type go 'require' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 730
Line range hint
5-5: Verify the correct usage of thetestingpackage to ensure that test functions are properly defined and executed.Verification successful
The
testingpackage is correctly used in theprotocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.gofile. The package is imported, and test functions are properly defined and executed usingt *testing.T.
testingpackage is imported.- Test functions are defined with
t *testing.T.- Sub-tests are run using
t.Run.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify correct usage of the `testing` package. # Test: Search for the usage of the `testing` package. Expect: Proper usage in test functions. rg --type python $'testing' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 109
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify correct usage of the `testing` package in Go test file. # Test: Search for the usage of the `testing` package. Expect: Proper usage in test functions. rg 'testing' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 1097
Line range hint
15-15: Ensure that theOrderstruct is correctly used and manipulated within the test cases.Verification successful
The
Orderstruct is extensively used and manipulated within the test cases inprotocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go. The search results show that various fields and methods of theOrderstruct are accessed and utilized correctly in different test scenarios.
- The
Orderstruct is instantiated and its fields are set using constants.- The
Orderstruct is passed to various functions and methods for testing order placement, matching, and other operations.- The fields of the
Orderstruct are accessed to verify expected outcomes in the test cases.Based on the gathered information, the
Orderstruct appears to be used correctly within the test cases.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the correct usage of the `Order` struct. # Test: Search for usage of the `Order` struct. Expect: Correct fields and methods are accessed. rg --type python $'Order' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 107
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the correct usage of the `Order` struct. # Test: Search for usage of the `Order` struct. Expect: Correct fields and methods are accessed. rg --type go 'Order' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 73145
Line range hint
13-13: Check the correct instantiation and configuration of theMemClobPriceTimePriorityobject to ensure it aligns with the system's requirements.Verification successful
The instantiation of
MemClobPriceTimePrioritywith the parameterfalsealigns with the constructor's definition, which setsgenerateOffchainUpdatestofalseandgenerateOrderbookUpdatestofalse. This configuration appears consistent across multiple instances in the test file.
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go: Multiple instances ofNewMemClobPriceTimePriority(false).The parameter
falseforgenerateOffchainUpdatesis correctly used according to the constructor's definition.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the correct instantiation of `MemClobPriceTimePriority`. # Test: Search for instantiation of `MemClobPriceTimePriority`. Expect: Correct parameters and usage. rg --type python $'MemClobPriceTimePriority' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 126
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the correct instantiation of `MemClobPriceTimePriority`. # Test: Search for instantiation of `MemClobPriceTimePriority`. Expect: Correct parameters and usage. rg --type go 'MemClobPriceTimePriority' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 420
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the definition and parameters of `NewMemClobPriceTimePriority`. # Test: Search for the definition of `NewMemClobPriceTimePriority`. Expect: Understand the parameters and their significance. rg --type go 'func NewMemClobPriceTimePriority'Length of output: 118
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Retrieve the full definition of `NewMemClobPriceTimePriority`. # Extract the full definition of `NewMemClobPriceTimePriority` from the file. rg --type go --context 10 'func NewMemClobPriceTimePriority' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.goLength of output: 677
Line range hint
7-7: Check for the appropriate use of mock objects to simulate external dependencies in unit tests.Verification successful
The search results indicate that mock objects are being used in the
memclob_place_order_test.gofile. Themocks.MemClobKeeperobject is instantiated and methods are mocked usingmock.Anything.
memClobKeeper := mocks.MemClobKeeper{}memClobKeeper.On("AddOrderToOrderbookSubaccountUpdatesCheck", mock.Anything, mock.Anything, mock.Anything)memClobKeeper.On("GetStatePosition", mock.Anything, mock.Anything, mock.Anything)memClobKeeper.On("ValidateSubaccountEquityTierLimitForNewOrder", mock.Anything, mock.Anything)memClobKeeper.On("GetOrderFillAmount", mock.Anything, orderId)These lines confirm that mock objects are appropriately used to simulate external dependencies in the unit tests.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the appropriate use of mock objects. # Test: Search for mock object usage. Expect: Correct instantiation and usage. rg --type python $'mock' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 106
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the appropriate use of mock objects. # Test: Search for mock object usage. Expect: Correct instantiation and usage. rg 'mock' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 841
Line range hint
17-17: Verify the proper handling and propagation of errors within the test functions to ensure robust error handling.Verification successful
The search results indicate that there are references to errors within the test file, but they are mostly comments and variable declarations. To ensure robust error handling, we need to verify if the test functions properly handle and propagate errors.
The search results show that the test functions in
memclob_place_order_test.godo include proper error handling usingrequire.ErrorIs,require.NoError, andrequire.Error. This indicates that errors are being checked and handled appropriately within the test functions.
require.ErrorIs(t, err, types.ErrOrderFullyFilled)require.NoError(t, err)require.NoError(t, json.Unmarshal(gr.Metrics, &jsonMetrics))require.Error(t, err, types.ErrInvalidReplacement)These patterns confirm that the test functions are verifying the presence or absence of errors as expected.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify proper error handling in test functions. # Test: Search for error handling patterns. Expect: Proper checks and handling of errors. rg --type python $'error' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 107
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify proper error handling in test functions. # Test: Search for error handling patterns. Expect: Proper checks and handling of errors. rg --type go 'error' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 798
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify proper error handling in test functions. # Test: Search for error handling within test functions. Expect: Proper checks and handling of errors. rg --type go 'require\.(Error|NoError)' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 359
Line range hint
3-3: Ensure all necessary imports are included and correctly utilized within the file.
| } | ||
| removalReason = types.OrderRemoval_REMOVAL_REASON_CONDITIONAL_FOK_COULD_NOT_BE_FULLY_FILLED | ||
| } else if errors.Is(err, types.ErrPostOnlyWouldCrossMakerOrder) { | ||
| if errors.Is(err, types.ErrPostOnlyWouldCrossMakerOrder) { |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Ensure proper error handling for new error conditions.
The new error conditions introduced for ErrPostOnlyWouldCrossMakerOrder and ErrWouldViolateIsolatedSubaccountConstraints are critical for the system's integrity. It's important to ensure that these errors are handled appropriately in upstream code to prevent any unintended order executions or state inconsistencies.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (5)
- protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/testutil/constants/stateful_orders.go (7 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/operations_to_propose_test.go (4 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/order_test.go (1 hunks)
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (3)
- protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go
- protocol/testutil/constants/stateful_orders.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go
Additional context used
Path-based instructions (2)
protocol/x/clob/types/order_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.protocol/x/clob/types/operations_to_propose_test.go (1)
Pattern
**/**: Do not include a walkthrough. For all comments on line changes that are longer than 15 lines, add a prefix to the comment of what lines you are commenting on (for example: "The changes from lines 100 to 200...". Add your comment to be on the last 15 lines of the chunk rather than adding your comment to the entire chunk.
Additional comments not posted (4)
protocol/x/clob/types/operations_to_propose_test.go (4)
71-71: The changes from lines 71 to 71 reflect the deprecation of FOK orders and their replacement with IOC orders.
169-169: The changes from lines 169 to 169 correctly update the test setup to use IOC orders instead of FOK, aligning with the new system behavior.
255-255: The changes from lines 255 to 255 ensure that the test cases are updated to handle IOC orders, maintaining consistency with the system's new order processing logic.
418-418: The changes from lines 418 to 418 properly integrate IOC orders into the operations queue tests, ensuring that the new order type is correctly handled in various scenarios.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 3
Outside diff range and nitpick comments (6)
protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go (1)
[!TIP]
Codebase VerificationThe search results indicate that the deprecated
Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILLis still referenced in several files, including operational logic and tests. This suggests that the deprecation might not be fully enforced across the codebase.
protocol/x/clob/types/order.go: Operational logic still checks forOrder_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL.protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations.go: Another operational logic reference.protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go: Test cases still use the deprecated value.These references need to be reviewed and potentially refactored to ensure the deprecation is fully enforced.
Analysis chain
Line range hint
228-245: The new test case for deprecated FOK orders is correctly implemented and verifies the new validation logic effectively.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that the deprecated FOK orders are handled correctly across the system. # Test: Search for the usage of `Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL` across the codebase. Expect: No operational logic should rely on this deprecated value. rg --type python $'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL'Length of output: 82
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that the deprecated FOK orders are handled correctly across the system. # Test: Search for the usage of `Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL` across the codebase. Expect: No operational logic should rely on this deprecated value. rg 'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL'Length of output: 960
protocol/x/clob/e2e/isolated_subaccount_orders_test.go (1)
Line range hint
183-184: Undefined variables in test cases.- PlaceOrder_Alice_Num0_Id0_Clob0_Buy5_Price10_GTB20 - PlaceOrder_Bob_Num0_Id0_Clob0_Sell5_Price10_GTB20 + // Correctly define or import the necessary variables for these ordersThe static analysis tool
golangci-linthas identified thatPlaceOrder_Alice_Num0_Id0_Clob0_Buy5_Price10_GTB20andPlaceOrder_Bob_Num0_Id0_Clob0_Sell5_Price10_GTB20are undefined. This could be due to missing imports or definitions in the test file. Ensure these variables are correctly defined or imported to avoid runtime errors.indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts (1)
Line range hint
52-52: Consider removing redundant case clauses in switch statements.- case "UNRECOGNIZED": - default: - return Order_Side.UNRECOGNIZED;This change simplifies the switch statements by removing unnecessary cases that are covered by the default case.
Also applies to: 53-53, 69-69, 164-164, 165-165, 184-184, 247-247, 248-248, 264-264
protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go (1)
Line range hint
12-12: Undefined variables detected. Ensure all referenced variables are defined or imported correctly.+ import "github.com/dydxprotocol/v4-chain/protocol/x/clob/types"Also applies to: 19-19, 26-26, 187-187, 194-194, 201-201, 404-404, 411-411, 418-418, 635-635, 642-642, 649-649, 656-656, 887-887, 894-894, 901-901, 943-943, 950-950, 957-957, 1098-1098, 1105-1105, 1112-1112
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (2)
Line range hint
10-2130: Review the use ofconstantsfor test data.Consider using local variables or a setup function to generate test data instead of relying on a global
constantspackage. This approach enhances test isolation and readability.
2130-2130: Clarify the test case description for "IOC Taker replaces unfilled non IOC order".The description of this test case could be more detailed to explain why the replacement is invalid, which would help in understanding the expected behavior without diving deep into the code.
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files ignored due to path filters (1)
protocol/x/clob/types/order.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.go
Files selected for processing (25)
- indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts (2 hunks)
- proto/dydxprotocol/clob/order.proto (1 hunks)
- protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/testutil/constants/stateful_orders.go (7 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/conditional_orders_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/equity_tier_limit_test.go (6 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/isolated_subaccount_orders_test.go (5 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_matches_test.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_removal_test.go (4 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_long_term_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_stateful_validation_test.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/simulation/place_order.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/errors.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders_test.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/operations_to_propose_test.go (4 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/order_test.go (1 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders_test.go
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (16)
- proto/dydxprotocol/clob/order.proto
- protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.go
- protocol/testutil/constants/stateful_orders.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/conditional_orders_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/equity_tier_limit_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_matches_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_removal_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_long_term_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_stateful_validation_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.go
- protocol/x/clob/simulation/place_order.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/errors.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/operations_to_propose_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/order_test.go
Additional context used
Learnings (1)
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (1)
User: jonfung-dydx PR: dydxprotocol/v4-chain#1009 File: protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go:4108-4108 Timestamp: 2024-02-05T20:01:55.204Z Learning: The `assertPlaceOrderOffchainMessages` function in `memclob_test_util.go` indeed requires `ctx` as a parameter for its operations, contrary to the initial comment made.
golangci-lint
protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order.go
12-12: undefined: MsgPlaceOrder (typecheck)
14-14: undefined: Order (typecheck)
20-20: undefined: MsgPlaceOrder (typecheck)
15-15: undefined: MsgPlaceOrder (typecheck)
24-24: undefined: ModuleName (typecheck)
32-32: undefined: Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL (typecheck)
33-33: undefined: ErrDeprecatedField (typecheck)
42-42: undefined: Order_Side_name (typecheck)
43-43: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderSide (typecheck)
46-46: undefined: Order_TimeInForce_name (typecheck)
47-47: undefined: ErrInvalidTimeInForce (typecheck)
50-50: undefined: Order_ConditionType_name (typecheck)
51-51: undefined: ErrInvalidConditionType (typecheck)
54-54: undefined: Order_SIDE_UNSPECIFIED (typecheck)
55-55: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderSide (typecheck)
59-59: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderQuantums (typecheck)
66-66: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderGoodTilBlock (typecheck)
71-71: undefined: ErrInvalidStatefulOrderGoodTilBlockTime (typecheck)
76-76: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderFlag (typecheck)
80-80: undefined: ErrLongTermOrdersCannotRequireImmediateExecution (typecheck)
84-84: undefined: ErrReduceOnlyDisabled (typecheck)
88-88: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderSubticks (typecheck)
92-92: undefined: Order_CONDITION_TYPE_UNSPECIFIED (typecheck)
93-93: undefined: ErrInvalidConditionType (typecheck)
97-97: undefined: ErrInvalidConditionalOrderTriggerSubticks (typecheck)
100-100: undefined: Order_CONDITION_TYPE_UNSPECIFIED (typecheck)
101-101: undefined: ErrInvalidConditionType (typecheck)
106-106: undefined: ErrInvalidConditionalOrderTriggerSubticks (typecheck)
protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go
13-13: undefined: MsgPlaceOrder (typecheck)
17-17: undefined: MsgPlaceOrder (typecheck)
18-18: undefined: Order (typecheck)
19-19: undefined: OrderId (typecheck)
30-30: undefined: MsgPlaceOrder (typecheck)
31-31: undefined: Order (typecheck)
32-32: undefined: OrderId (typecheck)
44-44: undefined: Order (typecheck)
45-45: undefined: OrderId (typecheck)
51-51: undefined: Order_Side (typecheck)
54-54: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderSide (typecheck)
65-65: undefined: Order_SIDE_BUY (typecheck)
66-66: undefined: Order_TimeInForce (typecheck)
69-69: undefined: ErrInvalidTimeInForce (typecheck)
80-80: undefined: Order_SIDE_BUY (typecheck)
81-81: undefined: Order_ConditionType (typecheck)
84-84: undefined: ErrInvalidConditionType (typecheck)
97-97: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderSide (typecheck)
108-108: undefined: Order_SIDE_BUY (typecheck)
111-111: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderQuantums (typecheck)
126-126: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderGoodTilBlock (typecheck)
142-142: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderFlag (typecheck)
152-152: undefined: OrderIdFlags_LongTerm (typecheck)
158-158: undefined: ErrInvalidStatefulOrderGoodTilBlockTime (typecheck)
168-168: undefined: OrderIdFlags_Conditional (typecheck)
174-174: undefined: ErrInvalidStatefulOrderGoodTilBlockTime (typecheck)
184-184: undefined: OrderIdFlags_LongTerm (typecheck)
188-188: undefined: Order_GoodTilBlockTime (typecheck)
191-191: undefined: Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOC (typecheck)
194-194: undefined: ErrLongTermOrdersCannotRequireImmediateExecution (typecheck)
207-207: undefined: Order_GoodTilBlock (typecheck)
210-210: undefined: ErrInvalidOrderSubticks (typecheck)
223-223: undefined: Order_GoodTilBlock (typecheck)
239-239: undefined: Order_GoodTilBlock (typecheck)
241-241: undefined: Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL (typecheck)
245-245: undefined: ErrDeprecatedField (typecheck)
255-255: undefined: OrderIdFlags_ShortTerm (typecheck)
261-261: undefined: Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOC (typecheck)
274-274: undefined: OrderIdFlags_LongTerm (typecheck)
278-278: undefined: Order_GoodTilBlockTime (typecheck)
280-280: undefined: Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_UNSPECIFIED (typecheck)
284-284: undefined: ErrReduceOnlyDisabled (typecheck)
294-294: undefined: OrderIdFlags_Conditional (typecheck)
298-298: undefined: Order_GoodTilBlockTime (typecheck)
300-300: undefined: Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_UNSPECIFIED (typecheck)
301-301: undefined: Order_CONDITION_TYPE_STOP_LOSS (typecheck)
306-306: undefined: ErrReduceOnlyDisabled (typecheck)
316-316: undefined: OrderIdFlags_Conditional (typecheck)
324-324: undefined: Order_CONDITION_TYPE_TAKE_PROFIT (typecheck)
347-347: undefined: ErrInvalidConditionType (typecheck)
protocol/x/clob/e2e/isolated_subaccount_orders_test.go
183-183: undefined: PlaceOrder_Alice_Num0_Id0_Clob0_Buy5_Price10_GTB20 (typecheck)
184-184: undefined: PlaceOrder_Bob_Num0_Id0_Clob0_Sell5_Price10_GTB20 (typecheck)
protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go
12-12: undefined: Alice_Num0 (typecheck)
19-19: undefined: Alice_Num0 (typecheck)
26-26: undefined: Alice_Num0 (typecheck)
187-187: undefined: Alice_Num1 (typecheck)
194-194: undefined: Alice_Num1 (typecheck)
201-201: undefined: Alice_Num1 (typecheck)
404-404: undefined: Bob_Num0 (typecheck)
411-411: undefined: Bob_Num0 (typecheck)
418-418: undefined: Bob_Num0 (typecheck)
635-635: undefined: Bob_Num1 (typecheck)
642-642: undefined: Carl_Num0 (typecheck)
649-649: undefined: Carl_Num0 (typecheck)
656-656: undefined: Carl_Num0 (typecheck)
887-887: undefined: Carl_Num1 (typecheck)
894-894: undefined: Carl_Num1 (typecheck)
901-901: undefined: Carl_Num1 (typecheck)
943-943: undefined: Dave_Num0 (typecheck)
950-950: undefined: Dave_Num0 (typecheck)
957-957: undefined: Dave_Num0 (typecheck)
1098-1098: undefined: Dave_Num1 (typecheck)
1105-1105: undefined: Dave_Num1 (typecheck)
1112-1112: undefined: Dave_Num1 (typecheck)
Biome
indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts
[error] 52-52: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 53-53: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 69-69: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 164-164: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 165-165: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 184-184: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 247-247: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 248-248: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 264-264: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
Additional comments not posted (13)
protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (1)
Line range hint
434-445: The new test cases for reduce-only orders are comprehensive and correctly validate the expected behavior under various scenarios.Verification successful
The search results indicate that
Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOCandOrder_TIME_IN_FORCE_UNSPECIFIEDare used extensively across the codebase, particularly in test files and constants definitions. This suggests that the handling of these order types is well-integrated and tested within the system.
- The occurrences in
protocol/testutil/constants/orders.goandprotocol/testutil/constants/stateful_orders.goshow that these constants are defined and likely used in various test scenarios.- The occurrences in
protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.goand other test files indicate that these order types are being tested for correct behavior.- The presence in
protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations.goand other implementation files suggests that the logic for handling these order types is implemented and checked.Given this comprehensive integration and testing, the changes in
protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.goappear to be consistent with the rest of the codebase.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that reduce-only orders are handled correctly across the system. # Test: Search for the usage of `Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOC` and `Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_UNSPECIFIED` across the codebase. Expect: Correct handling in all scenarios. rg --type python $'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOC|Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_UNSPECIFIED'Length of output: 107
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that reduce-only orders are handled correctly across the system. # Test: Search for the usage of `Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOC` and `Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_UNSPECIFIED` across the codebase. Expect: Correct handling in all scenarios. rg --type go 'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOC|Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_UNSPECIFIED'Length of output: 4183
protocol/x/clob/e2e/isolated_subaccount_orders_test.go (3)
38-45: Update to IOC orders aligns with PR objectives.This change correctly updates the order type from FOK to IOC, aligning with the deprecation of FOK orders as described in the PR summary and AI-generated summary.
Line range hint
525-543: Correct implementation of IOC orders for cross perpetual positions.This segment correctly implements the placement of IOC orders for cross perpetual positions, ensuring that the system's constraints on isolated and cross perpetual positions are adhered to.
Line range hint
484-502: Ensure consistency in order placement for isolated subaccounts.This test case introduces an IOC order for a cross perpetual, which should be verified against the system's constraints to ensure it does not violate isolated subaccount constraints.
indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts (2)
104-105: Deprecation ofTIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILLis correctly annotated.
140-141: Deprecation ofTIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILLin the SDK type enum is also correctly annotated.protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go (3)
973-973: Ensure the handling of Post-Only orders that would cross the book is correctly implemented.
665-666: Ensure the replacement logic for FOK orders with IOC orders is correctly implemented.Verification successful
The replacement logic for FOK orders with IOC orders is present in the test file. However, we need to ensure that it is correctly implemented and covers all necessary scenarios.
The replacement logic for FOK orders with IOC orders is correctly implemented in the test file
protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go. The test caseTestShortTermOrderReplacementsincludes the necessary logic to verify this replacement.
ioc_replacement.Order.TimeInForce = clobtypes.Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOCis present in the test case.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the replacement logic for FOK orders with IOC orders in the test cases. # Test: Search for the replacement logic in the test cases. Expect: Only occurrences of the new logic. rg --type go $'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOC' protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.goLength of output: 155
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the implementation of the replacement logic for FOK orders with IOC orders. # Test: Search for the implementation of the replacement logic in the test cases. rg --type go 'ioc_replacement.Order.TimeInForce = clobtypes.Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOC' protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go # Test: Check for any missing test cases related to the replacement logic. rg --type go 'TestShortTermOrderReplacements' protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.goLength of output: 347
973-973: Ensure the cancellation logic for partially filled orders is correctly implemented.Verification successful
To ensure the cancellation logic for partially filled orders is correctly implemented, we need to analyze the context around the occurrences of
CancelOrderandNewMsgCancelOrderShortTermin the test file. This will help us verify if the test cases specifically cover partially filled orders.
The context extracted from the test file
protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.goshows that the cancellation logic for partially filled orders is indeed covered in the test cases. Specifically, there are test cases named "Cancel partially filled short term order in same block" and "Cancel partially filled short term order in next block" which verify the cancellation behavior for partially filled orders.
- The test case "Cancel partially filled short term order in same block" ensures that an order partially filled within the same block is correctly canceled.
- The test case "Cancel partially filled short term order in next block" ensures that an order partially filled across different blocks is correctly canceled.
These test cases confirm that the cancellation logic for partially filled orders is implemented and tested.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify the cancellation logic for partially filled orders in the test cases. # Test: Search for the cancellation logic in the test cases. Expect: Only occurrences of the new logic. rg --type go $'CancelOrder' protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.goLength of output: 1376
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Extract the context around the occurrences of CancelOrder and NewMsgCancelOrderShortTerm in the test file. # Extract 10 lines of context around each occurrence of CancelOrder rg --type go -C 10 'CancelOrder' protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go # Extract 10 lines of context around each occurrence of NewMsgCancelOrderShortTerm rg --type go -C 10 'NewMsgCancelOrderShortTerm' protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.goLength of output: 7982
protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go (1)
1204-1226: The addition of new IOC orders aligns with the PR's objective to shift from FOK to IOC orders.protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (3)
2130-2130: Validate error handling for fully filled orders inTestAddOrderToOrderbook_ErrorPlaceNewFullyFilledOrder.Verification successful
The function
TestAddOrderToOrderbook_ErrorPlaceNewFullyFilledOrdercorrectly handles the scenario where an order is already fully filled before placement. The test sets up a fully filled order and verifies that placing such an order returns the appropriate error (types.ErrOrderFullyFilled).
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.golines 2713-2742Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Validate that fully filled orders are correctly handled. # Test: Search for handling of fully filled orders. rg --type go 'fully filled orders' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 88
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Search for the implementation of the function TestAddOrderToOrderbook_ErrorPlaceNewFullyFilledOrder. # Test: Search for the function definition. ast-grep --lang go --pattern 'func TestAddOrderToOrderbook_ErrorPlaceNewFullyFilledOrder($_) { $$$ }'Length of output: 3087
2130-2130: Ensure proper handling of preexisting matches inTestPlaceOrder_MatchOrders_PreexistingMatches.Verification successful
The function
TestPlaceOrder_MatchOrders_PreexistingMatchesincludes various test cases that handle preexisting matches in the order book. The test cases are designed to verify different scenarios, including partially matched orders, fully matched orders, and various error conditions. Each test case specifies the expected outcomes, including filled sizes, order statuses, and expected errors.The test case
"IOC Taker replaces unfilled non IOC order"specifically tests the scenario where an Immediate-Or-Cancel (IOC) order replaces a non-IOC order that has not been filled. The expected outcome for this test case is an error (types.ErrInvalidReplacement), indicating that the replacement is invalid.Based on the detailed implementation and the various scenarios covered, it appears that the handling of preexisting matches is thoroughly tested.
- The function
TestPlaceOrder_MatchOrders_PreexistingMatchescorrectly handles preexisting matches.- The test case
"IOC Taker replaces unfilled non IOC order"is appropriately defined and expects an error for invalid replacement.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that preexisting matches are correctly processed. # Test: Search for handling of preexisting matches in the function. rg --type go 'preexisting matches' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 88
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Locate the function `TestPlaceOrder_MatchOrders_PreexistingMatches` and examine its implementation. # Search for the function definition in the test file. ast-grep --lang go --pattern 'func TestPlaceOrder_MatchOrders_PreexistingMatches($_) { $$$ }' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.goLength of output: 103833
2130-2130: Ensure comprehensive testing of invalid order sides inTestAddOrderToOrderbook_PanicsOnInvalidSide.
| // Check for deprecated fields. | ||
| if msg.Order.TimeInForce == Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL { | ||
| return errorsmod.Wrapf(ErrDeprecatedField, "Fill-or-kill has been deprecated") | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Tip
Codebase Verification
The search results indicate that the deprecated Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL is still present in several parts of the codebase, including operational logic and tests. Here are the key findings:
-
Operational Logic:
protocol/x/clob/types/order.go: The methodRequiresImmediateExecutionstill checks forOrder_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL.protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations.go: There is a check forOrder_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILLin the order removal process.
-
Tests:
protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go: Tests include orders withOrder_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL.protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go: End-to-end tests include orders withOrder_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL.
-
Protobuf Definitions:
protocol/x/clob/types/order.pb.goandprotocol/indexer/protocol/v1/types/clob.pb.go: The deprecated value is still defined in the protobuf files.
Given these findings, it is clear that the deprecated Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL is still being used in both operational logic and tests. This contradicts the intent to deprecate this value.
Action Required:
-
Remove or Refactor Operational Logic:
- Refactor the
RequiresImmediateExecutionmethod inprotocol/x/clob/types/order.goto remove the check forOrder_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL. - Update the order removal logic in
protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations.goto remove the dependency onOrder_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL.
- Refactor the
-
Update Tests:
- Modify the tests in
protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.goandprotocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.goto avoid using the deprecated value.
- Modify the tests in
-
Protobuf Definitions:
- Consider removing the deprecated value from the protobuf definitions if it is no longer needed.
Locations to Address:
protocol/x/clob/types/order.goprotocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations.goprotocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.goprotocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.goprotocol/x/clob/types/order.pb.goprotocol/indexer/protocol/v1/types/clob.pb.go
Analysis chain
The implementation of the check for deprecated FOK orders is correct and well-integrated with the existing error handling and telemetry.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Verify that the deprecated FOK orders are handled correctly across the system.
# Test: Search for the usage of `Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL` across the codebase. Expect: No operational logic should rely on this deprecated value.
rg --type python $'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL'
Length of output: 82
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Verify that the deprecated FOK orders are handled correctly across the system.
# Test: Search for the usage of `Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL` across the codebase. Expect: No operational logic should rely on this deprecated value.
rg 'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL'
Length of output: 960
Script:
#!/bin/bash
# Description: Extract relevant lines from files containing `Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL` to analyze the context of its usage.
# Extract lines from protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go
rg --context 5 'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL' protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go
# Extract lines from protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order.go
rg --context 5 'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL' protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order.go
# Extract lines from protocol/x/clob/types/order.pb.go
rg --context 5 'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL' protocol/x/clob/types/order.pb.go
# Extract lines from protocol/x/clob/types/order.go
rg --context 5 'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL' protocol/x/clob/types/order.go
# Extract lines from protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go
rg --context 5 'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL' protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go
# Extract lines from protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations.go
rg --context 5 'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL' protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations.go
# Extract lines from protocol/indexer/protocol/v1/types/clob.pb.go
rg --context 5 'Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL' protocol/indexer/protocol/v1/types/clob.pb.go
Length of output: 3781
Tools
golangci-lint
32-32: undefined: Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL (typecheck)
33-33: undefined: ErrDeprecatedField (typecheck)
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files ignored due to path filters (1)
protocol/x/clob/types/order.pb.gois excluded by!**/*.pb.go
Files selected for processing (25)
- indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts (2 hunks)
- proto/dydxprotocol/clob/order.proto (1 hunks)
- protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/testutil/constants/stateful_orders.go (7 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/conditional_orders_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/equity_tier_limit_test.go (6 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/isolated_subaccount_orders_test.go (5 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_matches_test.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_removal_test.go (4 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_long_term_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_stateful_validation_test.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/simulation/place_order.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/errors.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders_test.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go (3 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/operations_to_propose_test.go (4 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/order_test.go (1 hunks)
Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (21)
- proto/dydxprotocol/clob/order.proto
- protocol/testing/e2e/gov/wind_down_market_test.go
- protocol/testutil/constants/orders.go
- protocol/testutil/constants/stateful_orders.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/conditional_orders_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/equity_tier_limit_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/isolated_subaccount_orders_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/long_term_orders_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_matches_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/e2e/order_removal_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_long_term_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/keeper/process_operations_stateful_validation_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.go
- protocol/x/clob/simulation/place_order.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/errors.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/match_with_orders_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/message_place_order_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/operations_to_propose_test.go
- protocol/x/clob/types/order_test.go
Additional context used
Learnings (1)
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (1)
User: jonfung-dydx PR: dydxprotocol/v4-chain#1009 File: protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go:4108-4108 Timestamp: 2024-02-05T20:01:55.204Z Learning: The `assertPlaceOrderOffchainMessages` function in `memclob_test_util.go` indeed requires `ctx` as a parameter for its operations, contrary to the initial comment made.
Biome
indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts
[error] 52-52: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 53-53: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 69-69: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 164-164: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 165-165: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 184-184: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 247-247: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 248-248: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
[error] 264-264: Useless case clause. (lint/complexity/noUselessSwitchCase)
because the default clause is present:
Unsafe fix: Remove the useless case.
Additional comments not posted (16)
protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go (2)
434-434: Ensure the error message aligns with the intended behavior for reduce only orders.Verification successful
The error message
ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSizeis used consistently across the codebase and aligns with the intended behavior for reduce only orders.
protocol/x/clob/types/errors.go: Definition of the error message.protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.go: Usage in the implementation.protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_reduce_only_test.go: Usage in tests.protocol/x/clob/keeper/orders.go: Usage in the order processing logic.protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.go: Usage in end-to-end tests.protocol/indexer/shared/order_removal_reason.go: Usage in order removal logic.Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that the error message for reduce only orders is consistent across the codebase. # Test: Search for the error message usage. Expect: Consistent usage across the codebase. rg --type go $'ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSize'Length of output: 1543
445-445: Confirm that the error handling for buy reduce only orders is consistent with the system's expectations.Verification successful
The search results indicate that
ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSizeis defined and used in multiple places across the codebase. To ensure that the error handling for buy reduce only orders is consistent with the system's expectations, we need to review the definition and usage of this error in detail.
The error
ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSizeis defined as follows:ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSize = errorsmod.Register( ModuleName, 2001, "Reduce-only orders cannot increase the position size", )The usage of this error in the context of error handling is consistent across the codebase. It is used in various files to ensure that reduce-only orders do not increase the position size, which aligns with the system's expectations. Specifically, it is used in:
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.goprotocol/x/clob/keeper/orders.goprotocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.goThese usages confirm that the error handling for buy reduce only orders is consistent and correctly implemented.
Scripts executed
The following scripts were executed for the analysis:
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Verify that the error handling for buy reduce only orders is consistent. # Test: Search for the error handling pattern. Expect: Consistent handling across the codebase. rg --type go $'ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSize'Length of output: 1543
Script:
#!/bin/bash # Description: Gather detailed information about the definition and usage of ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSize. # 1. Display the definition of ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSize. echo "Definition of ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSize:" rg --type go --context 5 'ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSize = errorsmod.Register' protocol/x/clob/types/errors.go # 2. Display the usage of ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSize in the context of error handling. echo "Usage of ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSize in error handling:" rg --type go --context 5 'ErrReduceOnlyWouldIncreasePositionSize' protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob.go protocol/x/clob/keeper/orders.go protocol/x/clob/e2e/reduce_only_orders_test.goLength of output: 4779
indexer/packages/v4-protos/src/codegen/dydxprotocol/clob/order.ts (3)
104-105: Deprecation ofTIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILLis well-documented.This change aligns with the PR's objective to deprecate the FOK enum field. Ensure that all references and usages across the codebase are updated to reflect this deprecation.
140-141: Deprecation ofTIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILLis consistently applied across SDK types.This ensures that the deprecation is clear in both the standard and SDK-specific enumerations, maintaining consistency.
Line range hint
52-52: Consider simplifying the switch-case structures.
[REFACTOR_SUGGESTion]
The static analysis tool has identified several cases in theorder_SideFromJSON,order_SideToJSON,order_TimeInForceFromJSON, andorder_TimeInForceToJSONfunctions that are redundant due to the presence of a default case. Simplifying these could enhance readability and maintainability. Here's a proposed change for one such function:export function order_SideFromJSON(object: any): Order_Side { switch (object) { case 0: case "SIDE_UNSPECIFIED": return Order_Side.SIDE_UNSPECIFIED; case 1: case "SIDE_BUY": return Order_Side.SIDE_BUY; case 2: case "SIDE_SELL": return Order_Side.SIDE_SELL; default: return Order_Side.UNRECOGNIZED; } }Apply similar changes to other functions flagged by the static analysis.
Also applies to: 53-53, 69-69, 164-164, 165-165, 184-184, 247-247, 248-248, 264-264
protocol/x/clob/e2e/short_term_orders_test.go (2)
665-666: Update the test to reflect the deprecation of FOK orders.- ioc_replacement.Order.GoodTilOneof = &clobtypes.Order_GoodTilBlock{GoodTilBlock: 21} - ioc_replacement.Order.TimeInForce = clobtypes.Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOC + ioc_replacement.Order.GoodTilOneof = &clobtypes.Order_GoodTilBlock{GoodTilBlock: 21} + ioc_replacement.Order.TimeInForce = clobtypes.Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_IOCEnsure that the test reflects the new order type and the deprecated FOK orders are not used.
Likely invalid or redundant comment.
973-973: Ensure consistency in handling IOC orders.This script checks for the consistent handling of IOC orders across different files, ensuring that the new order type is integrated properly without discrepancies.
protocol/x/clob/memclob/memclob_place_order_test.go (9)
2130-2130: The test cases withinTestPlaceOrder_AddOrderToOrderbookcover a good range of scenarios, including placing valid buy and sell orders on an empty orderbook, and handling orders with different price levels. It's crucial to ensure that the expected outcomes, such asexpectedOrderStatusandexpectedToReplaceOrder, are correctly asserted in each case to validate the order book's behavior accurately.
2130-2130: The test cases inTestPlaceOrder_MatchOrdersare well-structured to cover various matching scenarios, including partial and full matches. However, ensure that the collateralization checks are thoroughly tested, especially in scenarios where orders might fail these checks after being partially filled. This is crucial for maintaining the integrity of the trading system under adverse conditions.
2130-2130: The functionTestPlaceOrder_MatchOrders_PreexistingMatcheseffectively tests complex scenarios where preexisting matches affect new order placements. It's important to verify that the state of the order book is consistent before and after the test runs, ensuring that preexisting matches are handled correctly and do not lead to unexpected behavior.
2130-2130:TestPlaceOrder_MatchOrders_CollatCheckFailureis crucial for testing the robustness of the trading system against collateralization failures. Ensure that each scenario properly simulates the failure conditions and that the system behaves as expected, either by rejecting the orders or by handling them according to the configured business rules.
2130-2130: TheTestPlaceOrder_Telemetryfunction is well-implemented to ensure that telemetry data is correctly generated and recorded during order placements. This is essential for monitoring and debugging the system in production. Verify that all telemetry counters and samples are correctly configured and that the data reflects the actual operations performed by the system.
2130-2130:TestPlaceOrder_GenerateOffchainUpdatesFalse_NoMessagesSentcorrectly tests that no offchain update messages are sent when the feature is disabled. This is important for scenarios where offchain communication needs to be restricted. Ensure that the test accurately reflects the system's configuration and that the assertions are robust.
2130-2130:TestPlaceOrder_DuplicateOrdereffectively tests the system's resilience against duplicate orders, ensuring that an appropriate error is returned. This is crucial for preventing unintended trades and maintaining the integrity of the order book. Confirm that the error handling is consistent with the system's requirements and that the test covers all necessary scenarios.
2130-2130:TestPlaceOrder_ImmediateOrCancelthoroughly tests the IOC order functionality, covering scenarios where orders are fully matched, partially matched, or canceled if they would rest on the book. This is vital for ensuring that IOC orders behave as expected under various market conditions. Ensure that the test cases are comprehensive and that the expected outcomes are clearly defined and asserted.
2130-2130:TestPlaceOrder_PostOnlyprovides a detailed examination of the Post Only order functionality, ensuring that such orders do not cross the book and are handled correctly. It's important to verify that the scenarios tested reflect realistic trading conditions and that the system's responses are in line with the expected behavior for Post Only orders.
| expectedErr: types.ErrInvalidReplacement, | ||
| }, | ||
| "IOC Taker cannot replace unfilled non IOC order": { | ||
| "IOC Taker replaces unfilled non IOC order": { |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The test case "IOC Taker replaces unfilled non IOC order" seems to be testing the behavior of replacing a non-IOC order with an IOC order. However, the expected error types.ErrInvalidReplacement might not fully capture the specific scenario being tested, which is specific to IOC orders. Consider adding a more descriptive error or a comment explaining why this error is expected in this context.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 3
Outside diff range and nitpick comments (2)
protocol/app/upgrades/v6.0.0/upgrade.go (1)
41-55: Review logging and error handling inCreateUpgradeHandler.Consider enhancing the logging within
CreateUpgradeHandlerto include more details about the operations being performed, especially before and after critical operations likeremoveStatefulFOKOrders.protocol/x/clob/types/clob_keeper.go (1)
161-161: Document theGetAllStatefulOrdersmethod.The method
GetAllStatefulOrdersis added to theClobKeeperinterface but lacks documentation. Consider adding a comment explaining its purpose, especially how it interacts with stateful and non-stateful orders.
Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Files selected for processing (6)
- protocol/app/upgrades/v6.0.0/upgrade.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/app/upgrades/v6.0.0/upgrade_container_test.go (2 hunks)
- protocol/mocks/ClobKeeper.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/testing/containertest/containertest.sh (1 hunks)
- protocol/testing/containertest/node.go (1 hunks)
- protocol/x/clob/types/clob_keeper.go (1 hunks)
Files skipped from review due to trivial changes (1)
- protocol/testing/containertest/containertest.sh
Additional comments not posted (1)
protocol/mocks/ClobKeeper.go (1)
203-221: The implementation ofGetAllStatefulOrdersmethod in the mockClobKeeperclass is correct and aligns with standard practices for mocking in tests.
| func removeStatefulFOKOrders(ctx sdk.Context, k clobtypes.ClobKeeper) { | ||
| allStatefulOrders := k.GetAllStatefulOrders(ctx) | ||
| for _, order := range allStatefulOrders { | ||
| if order.TimeInForce == clobtypes.Order_TIME_IN_FORCE_FILL_OR_KILL { | ||
| // Remove the orders from state. | ||
| k.MustRemoveStatefulOrder(ctx, order.OrderId) | ||
|
|
||
| // Send indexer event for removal of stateful order. | ||
| k.GetIndexerEventManager().AddTxnEvent( | ||
| ctx, | ||
| indexerevents.SubtypeStatefulOrder, | ||
| indexerevents.StatefulOrderEventVersion, | ||
| indexer_manager.GetBytes( | ||
| indexerevents.NewStatefulOrderRemovalEvent( | ||
| order.OrderId, | ||
| indexershared.ConvertOrderRemovalReasonToIndexerOrderRemovalReason( | ||
| clobtypes.OrderRemoval_REMOVAL_REASON_CONDITIONAL_FOK_COULD_NOT_BE_FULLY_FILLED, | ||
| ), | ||
| ), | ||
| ), | ||
| ) | ||
| } | ||
| } | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Ensure proper error handling in removeStatefulFOKOrders.
The function removeStatefulFOKOrders lacks error handling for the operations MustRemoveStatefulOrder and AddTxnEvent. Consider adding error checks or using non-Must versions of these methods if available.
| @@ -43,145 +44,151 @@ func preUpgradeSetups(node *containertest.Node, t *testing.T) { | |||
|
|
|||
| func preUpgradeChecks(node *containertest.Node, t *testing.T) { | |||
| // Add test for your upgrade handler logic below | |||
| preUpgradeStatefulOrderCheck(node, t) | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Enhance the upgrade test coverage.
Consider adding more comprehensive tests in preUpgradeStatefulOrderCheck and postUpgradeStatefulOrderCheck to cover scenarios where orders might not be removed as expected. This could include checks for orders with different conditions or incorrect data.
Also applies to: 52-52
| // Broadcast a tx to the node given the message and a signer address. | ||
| func BroadcastTxWithoutValidateBasic[M cosmos.Msg](n *Node, message M, signer string) (err error) { | ||
| clientContext, flags, err := n.getContextForBroadcastTx(signer) | ||
| if err != nil { | ||
| return err | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| txFactory, err := tx.NewFactoryCLI(*clientContext, flags) | ||
| if err != nil { | ||
| return err | ||
| } | ||
|
|
||
| // Use default gas limit and gas fee. | ||
| txFactory = txFactory.WithGas(constants.TestGasLimit).WithFees(constants.TestFee) | ||
|
|
||
| if err = tx.BroadcastTx(*clientContext, txFactory, message); err != nil { | ||
| return err | ||
| } | ||
| return nil | ||
| } |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review the use of BroadcastTxWithoutValidateBasic.
The function BroadcastTxWithoutValidateBasic bypasses basic validation checks. While this can be useful for testing, it should be used with caution to avoid introducing errors in production-like environments. Consider documenting the intended use cases and potential risks associated with this function.
jayy04
changed the title
Changelist
[Describe or list the changes made in this PR]
Test Plan
[Describe how this PR was tested (if applicable)]
Author/Reviewer Checklist
state-breakinglabel.indexer-postgres-breakinglabel.PrepareProposalorProcessProposal, manually add the labelproposal-breaking.feature:[feature-name].backport/[branch-name].refactor,chore,bug.Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
Fill or Kill (FOK)order type and replaced it withImmediate or Cancel (IOC)orders.Bug Fixes
Tests
Chores