pod/perlguts pod/perlhacktips - various updates and new content #22881
Conversation
| For 5.21.6 and up, to avoid recompiling XS, if you want to add a new interpreter | ||
| global variable while hacking on the interpreter, is to rename, repurpose, or | ||
| make into union, a current variable from F<intrpvar.h> without change its size, | ||
| alignment, and offset. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Preferably we'd fix this bug in the XS handshake, so that maint can add new members to the end of the interpreter structure.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
We would need 2 numbers/consts then, a fictional "ABI" my_perl struct that is frozen-ish, and the runtime my_perl struct has its normal CC length. But if == changes to >=, it won't detect interp fields like
https://github.com/Perl/perl5/blob/blead/intrpvar.h#L277
https://github.com/Perl/perl5/blob/blead/intrpvar.h#L520 (32b time_t vs 64b , windows mingw gcc hot mess 10-15 years ago)
big multi member struct, spec says the type has UB contents, and UB size (OS vendors choice)
https://codebrowser.dev/glibc/glibc/locale/bits/types/__locale_t.h.html#__locale_struct
pre-xs handshake segv, compiler upgrade, made glibc.so and std C disk .h not agree anymore, and segv the persons newer xs modules, but not his interp or old .so XS bin
https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1064271#c34
Also it might be time for XS handshake and your new reverse version of it (I can crash the sample if perl.dll and host exe dont agree on the my_perl struct), to pass a better file name than FILE or, allow a trapable fatal error.
A very very tiny API, would be needed to throw a "portable" die to root interp from an accidental 2nd interp/2nd libperl, or from the BOOT: XSUB of the broken 3rd party XS .so/.dll to root interp.
void arg2->cantAttach(void);
setjmp buffers and libc's internals of longjmp() have an above average risk of SEGVing. Remember Win32/64's eternal problem of multiple CRT DLLs in 1 proc. (5.41.8 has it right now, ws2_32.dll links against msvcrt.dll instead of linking against ntdll.dll for libc basics). A tiny api like, or just rename the XS___Module__bootstrap to XS___Module__bootstrap_v4108_A1F0 and move the handshake key into the symbol table of the .so/.dll.
My wishlist has an idea to remove the 1 fn/sym big WinOS .dll XS export table completely from XS. Just have dynaloder call DllMain with DWORD fdwReason *(U32)"PERL".
Debugging XS handshake, its harder than average, either you write code to print the offsets of all fields, and text diff that, or make a .i format it, cut out the interp struct, text diff it. Its most often for me, a Inline::C/EU::MM, -DFLAGS CCFLAGS problems. Even more sinister, last time I did the text diff both interp structs had the same line count!!!! It was a U16 U64 problem, and both aligned (hole) to 64b, so even XS handshake didn't catch that. interp structs were the same total size after standard C integer type alignment.
I will change that area of text to say the correct/intended design is adding members to bottom in maint, but current its not possible.
|
repushed, added some sentences says expanding the end interp struct in a maint release should be returned one day if someone can write better code than the current implementation, and is equally resistent against self built perls in /home, .rc mistakes, copy pasted binaries, incompatible CC upgrades, and really bad makefile.pls on cpan that don't work outside of their authors box. added some stories about extreme platforms perl runs on, since IT diverse than "Ubuntu on x64", and advice to think about future tech changes long after you wrote it |
See commit.