-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 273
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Can't create ISO NFS SR via XOA #1845
Comments
Which version are you using? |
@hoerup please just enter the host address first (not the path), then click on the "search" icon. |
Without path I get this in log:
But with the path I get this:
I'm using |
@hoerup you have to enter both the host and the path but in the two different inputs. |
Well, there's the problem - I never get more than one input field |
My bad, it's normal to have a single input. The error with the path is normal: you should not put the path in the server input. We cannot reproduce the other error. |
@hoerup normally, XenServer should return:
In your case, it's like XAPI didn't return a XML with the list of exports. |
The target is a Qnap nas running latest QTS(4.2). |
An interesting result would be to use |
Any news @hoerup ? I tried to reproduce here, without success :( |
Closing until we have news on this. |
Reopening to see if I can reproduce |
I can't reproduce here. Can you open a support tunnel that I test it myself in your XOA? |
I'm using XOA from source, but can deploy the turnkey appliance unless there is a way to open a support tunnel from the source build? I have re-deployed XOA to the same host where I am trying to set up the NFS mount, and getting the same symptoms. Also found this in the SMLog when trying to search the NFS through the UI:
|
Please just type the server IP address in the server field, NOT the full path. edit: hmm it seems you just entered the server address, correct? |
That error is with just the IP, as per the XOA screenshot above. |
Please import a XOA, create a support tunnel and then I'll try myself ASAP |
I'm just importing and upgrading, then I will open a tunnel. |
So it seems the problem is because the probe request (even on
It should be:
|
So not XO related. Closing but still eager to know what could be the root cause :) |
This will be fixed in the today's release. |
I have this problem running XCP-ng 7.6 with the latest patches, XOA 5.29.1, and a QNAP (TS-873U-RP) with the latest firmware 4.3.5.0760 Log message from Xen Orchestra
xe sr-probe
showmount
rpcinfo
manual mount
|
@nilsan as discussed, it's a XCP-ng/XenServer issue, due to NFS v4 only on the server. Please create the issue here on XCP-ng side: https://github.com/xcp-ng/xcp/issues |
I'll create the issue, but the problem is identical on both NFSv3 and NFSv4. |
I can't reproduce your issue if I have v3 enabled, so let's report what we can reproduce first ;) |
Not to piggyback on the same issue: xe sr-probe
mounts:
nfs info
|
My theory about this: xapi-project/sm#511 |
Another quick way that I was able to reproduce this on a fresh install of xcp-ng 8.1.0 and xen-orchestra (xo-server 5.64.1 and xo-web 5.67.0) is: Start a simple NFS (v4 +) docker container on a linux host:
Xen-orchestra log when trying to add NFS ISO server:
From xcp-ng host:
|
Can you show the result of |
Sure, looks like I had partially pasted the output in my previous comment.
|
What about |
|
So this is not exactly the same issue than the previous one. You should at least got a share list available. Fix that and then, we'll see the problem with XCP-ng/XO edit: Google says "Firewall issues", eg https://www.linuxhelp.com/questions/showmount-command-failure |
Well.. Im using NFS v4 (4, 4.1, 4.2 only) so to secure things a bit more (and since technically I dont need rpcbind and its friends), I didnt have portmapper service running. |
Okay.. looks like if I have rpcbind process running on port 111, XO is able to look up the NFS server.
Above, I was not running rpcbind (since its no longer a requirement for NFSv4) and was using I'm not sure (and maybe this is a "feature request") but maybe we should let users specify the
Thanks again! |
Okay so it works and the original issue with QNAP (not reporting the Regarding your feature request, yes, you can create a new issue for adding a SR with a path directly without doing a probe. |
When Using XenCenter I have no problem creating a NFS SR pointing to this NFSv3 export 192.168.12.4:/Public
When I try to do the same thing in Xen Orchestra I just get an error:
"Server Detection
unknown error from the peer"
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: