You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
The fallback ASDF (2.26) bundled with Quicklisp is too old to build many projects.
I understand the desire not to update it to a newer version, but I think that rather than distributing something that is explicitly broken (if you, for instance, install QL on an implementation which does not have ASDF, then (ql:quickload ...) will just break in mysterious ways for many QL-provided systems & this does not give a good impression) it would be preferable to detect that there is no ASDF, give a reasonable error, and bail out at setup time. I'd rather have a setup fail than have it 'succeed' but in fact be broken.
Obviously this is an opinionated issue: if you disagree feel free to close it!
If you agree I'd be willing to put in some work & a PR to excise the old ASDF version.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
The fallback ASDF (2.26) bundled with Quicklisp is too old to build many projects.
I understand the desire not to update it to a newer version, but I think that rather than distributing something that is explicitly broken (if you, for instance, install QL on an implementation which does not have ASDF, then
(ql:quickload ...)
will just break in mysterious ways for many QL-provided systems & this does not give a good impression) it would be preferable to detect that there is no ASDF, give a reasonable error, and bail out at setup time. I'd rather have a setup fail than have it 'succeed' but in fact be broken.Obviously this is an opinionated issue: if you disagree feel free to close it!
If you agree I'd be willing to put in some work & a PR to excise the old ASDF version.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: