ESP32-S3 with ES8388 #66

boondockadmin · 2023-02-04T23:00:03Z

boondockadmin
Feb 4, 2023

Hi,

I am trying to build a custom board with Audio. The Audiokit works fantastic, but I ran into problems with the ESP32-A1S chip by Aithinker, for having fewer GPIO left.

So, I tried to build a custom board using ESp32-S3 and ES8388 modules by PCBArtists. PCB Artist board link And I wired based on instructions from PCBArtists.

I am unable to communicate with the ES8388 board properly. I tried to copy the ES8388 driver and create a copy with pin mapped to ESp32 pins... Similar to the Kaluga board.

    i2c_config->sda_io_num = GPIO_NUM_8; // GPIO_NUM_18
    i2c_config->scl_io_num = GPIO_NUM_7; // GPIO_NUM_23

.....

AUDIO_NULL_CHECK(TAG_AI, i2s_config, return ESP_FAIL);
if (port == I2S_NUM_0 || port == I2S_NUM_1) {
    i2s_config->bck_io_num = GPIO_NUM_18;
    i2s_config->ws_io_num = GPIO_NUM_17;
    i2s_config->data_out_num = GPIO_NUM_12;
    i2s_config->data_in_num = GPIO_NUM_46;

#if ESP_IDF_VERSION > ESP_IDF_VERSION_VAL(4, 4, 0)
i2s_config->mck_io_num = GPIO_NUM_0;

I would appreciate any help. Here are some messages I get. I believe I2s is connecting successfully,

Info: Selected board: 4
Info: headphone detection is active
Debug: audio_hal_init
Debug: audio_calloc: 1 * 36
Debug: es8388_init
Debug: i2c_init
Info: i2c port: 0
Info: i2c sda: 8
Info: i2c scl: 7
Debug: void* i2c_bus_create(i2c_port_t, i2c_config_t*)
Info: i2c sda: 8
Info: i2c scl: 7
Info: i2c clk_speed: 100000
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=25 value=4
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=1 value=80
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=2 value=0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=53 value=160
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=55 value=208
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=57 value=208
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=8 value=0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=192
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=0 value=18
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=24 value=2
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=38 value=0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=39 value=144
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=42 value=144
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43 value=128
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=45 value=0
Debug: es8388_set_adc_dac_volume: 0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=27 value=0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=26 value=0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=60
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=255
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=9 value=187
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=10 value=80
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=11 value=2
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=13
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=13 value=2
Debug: es8388_set_adc_dac_volume: 0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=16 value=0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=17 value=0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=9
Debug: es8388_pa_power: true
Debug: audio_codec_initialize -> 0
Info: audio_codec_initialize-END-OK
Debug: es8388_config_i2s
Debug: es8388_config_fmt
Debug: i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=12
Debug: i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
Debug: es8388_set_bits_per_sample
Debug: i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=12
Debug: i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
Debug: es8388_set_voice_volume (HACK 1): 20
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=26 value=0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=27 value=0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=46 value=6
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=47 value=6
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=48 value=6
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=49 value=6
Info: i2s_set_pin
Debug: audio_hal_ctrl_codec
Info: Codec mode is 3, Ctrl:1
Debug: es8388_ctrl_state
Debug: es8388_start
Debug: i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43
Error: ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
[ 7085][E][Wire.cpp:392] requestFrom(): i2cRead returned Error -1
Error: ->p_wire->requestFrom 1->0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43 value=128
Debug: i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=2 value=240
Error: ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=2 value=0
Error: ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=0
Error: ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
Debug: es8388_start default is mode:3
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=60
Debug: es8388_set_voice_mute
Debug: i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=25
Error: ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=25 value=121
Debug: es8388_start default is mode:3
Debug: start default is decode mode:3
Error: setActive
Debug: audio_hal_set_volume: 50
Debug: es8388_set_voice_volume (HACK 1): 50
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=26 value=0
Error: ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=27 value=0
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=46 value=16
Error: ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=47 value=16
Error: ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=48 value=16
Error: ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
Debug: i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=49 value=16
Error: ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
Info: Total heap: 347044
Info: Free heap: 244836
Info: Total PSRAM: 0
Info: Free PSRAM: 0

Thanks,

Kaushlesh

Answered by pschatzmann

Feb 5, 2023

I just committed the following change: When you use board setting 10) generic_es8388 with PlatformIO, you can override each pin individually with the build_flags in the platformio.ini file in order to make them match with your current wirings.
For the available defines please check the board_def.h

View full answer

boondockadmin · 2023-02-04T23:01:46Z

boondockadmin
Feb 4, 2023
Author

Want to mention that I have exact same code running perfectly with ESP32 AudioKit by Aithinker. I created two environments on VS Code Platform IO, and I use that to switch between boards.

0 replies

pschatzmann · 2023-02-05T06:04:34Z

pschatzmann
Feb 5, 2023
Maintainer

The easiest is, if you stick with one of the existing board settings: 4) esp32_s2_kaluga_1_v1_2 (ES8311) will not work because that uses an ES8311 and you have a ES8388!

So can you still change the wires ? Otherwise you will need to create a new number in audiokit_board.h

1 reply

boondockadmin Feb 5, 2023
Author

Hi, Thanks for your response. I tested all my code on Aithinker Kit. But as I am connecting to the ham radio, I needed more GPIO to trigger PTT on the radio. So, I decided to use ESP32-S3. ES8311 is a single channel and I could not find any module to test my design. So I picked ES8388.

I did use board 5 ( ES8388 ) and changed all the GPIO in the board_pins_config.c file. From the looks of the debug output, I2C is connecting and communicating. I am doing some more testing to identify at which exact (es_write_reg(ES8388_ADDR,) does the code fails.

pschatzmann · 2023-02-05T06:32:45Z

pschatzmann
Feb 5, 2023
Maintainer

I just committed the following change: When you use board setting 10) generic_es8388 with PlatformIO, you can override each pin individually with the build_flags in the platformio.ini file in order to make them match with your current wirings.
For the available defines please check the board_def.h

1 reply

boondockadmin Feb 5, 2023
Author

That sounds good! I will try using board 10. btw... I used pins exactly like the esp32_s2_kaluga_1_v1_2 board. I haven't tried generic 10 yet. ill do that.

boondockadmin · 2023-02-05T22:02:46Z

boondockadmin
Feb 5, 2023
Author

The updated code was very helpful! Now I can use Board 10, and It works as expected now. Another unrelated issue I had was pulling up the I2C pins. The internal pullup doesn't help. I2C will work initially but once the ES8388 chip is initialized, I2C fails.

0 replies

jay6621 · 2023-04-02T06:37:27Z

jay6621
Apr 2, 2023

Hello There, I am also working on exact same setup ESP32S3 with ES8388 and using board 10 Generic ES8388,
after setting I set logger to Debug level, what I got is below output:

Info:    bool audiokit::AudioKit::begin(audiokit::AudioKitConfig)
Info:    Selected board: 10
E (898) gpio: gpio_set_intr_type(148): GPIO interrupt type error
Info:    headphone detection is active
Debug:   audio_hal_init
Debug:   audio_calloc: 1 * 36
Debug:   es8388_init
Debug:   i2c_init
Info:    i2c port: 0
Info:    i2c sda: 17
Info:    i2c scl: 18
Debug:   void* i2c_bus_create(i2c_port_t, i2c_config_t*)
Info:    i2c clk_speed: 100000
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=25 value=4
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=1 value=80
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=2 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=53 value=160
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=55 value=208
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=57 value=208
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=8 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=192
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=0 value=18
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=24 value=2
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=38 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=39 value=144
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=42 value=144
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43 value=128
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=45 value=0
Debug:   es8388_set_adc_dac_volume: 0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=27 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=26 value=0
Info:    dac_output 2
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=60
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=255
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=9 value=187
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=10 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=11 value=2
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=13
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=13 value=2
Debug:   es8388_set_adc_dac_volume: 0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=16 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=17 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=9
Debug:   audio_codec_initialize -> 0
Info:    audio_codec_initialize-END-OK
Debug:   es8388_config_i2s
Debug:   es8388_config_fmt
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=8
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=16
Debug:   es8388_set_bits_per_sample
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
Debug:   es8388_set_voice_volume (HACK 2): 20
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=46 value=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=47 value=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=48 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=49 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=30 value=48
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=31 value=48
Debug:   setupI2S
Info:    i2s bck_io_num: 9
Info:    i2s ws_io_num: 45
Info:    i2s data_out_num: 10
Info:    i2s data_in_num: 8
Info:    i2s_set_pin
Info:    - bck_io_num: 9
Info:    - ws_io_num: 45
Info:    - data_out_num: 10
Info:    - data_in_num: 8
Info:    - mck_io_num: 16
Debug:   audio_hal_ctrl_codec
Info:    Codec mode is 1, Ctrl:1
Debug:   es8388_ctrl_state
Debug:   es8388_start
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43 value=128
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=0
Debug:   es8388_start default is mode:1
Debug:   start default is decode mode:1
Debug:   read: 1024
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0

I checked my pins more than 5 times all pin numbers are fine.
Any ideas is appreciated.
Thank you

2 replies

pschatzmann Apr 2, 2023
Maintainer

I recently also noticed this error message.
I did't see any negative impact however...

jay6621 Apr 2, 2023

Yes sir, But my mic data is all '0' Any ideas ?
I am using "Input" sketch from examples.

pschatzmann · 2023-04-02T06:49:04Z

pschatzmann
Apr 2, 2023
Maintainer

Did you try with both cfg.adc_input = AUDIO_HAL_ADC_INPUT_LINE1; or AUDIO_HAL_ADC_INPUT_LINE2

I would start testing on the output side (with a sine generator) which should be easier because by default the output goes to both output devices

2 replies

pschatzmann Apr 2, 2023
Maintainer

In regard of the error message, what headphone detection pin did you define ?

jay6621 Apr 2, 2023

I haven't define headphone detection pin sir.

jay6621 · 2023-04-02T07:01:54Z

jay6621
Apr 2, 2023

Yes I did try both AUDIO_HAL_ADC_INPUT_LINE1; or AUDIO_HAL_ADC_INPUT_LINE2 with no change in output.
As per your suggestion I did tried output with sinewave generator with no audio from speaker

Info:    bool audiokit::AudioKit::begin(audiokit::AudioKitConfig)
Info:    Selected board: 10
E (898) gpio: gpio_set_intr_type(148): GPIO interrupt type error
Info:    headphone detection is active
Debug:   audio_hal_init
Debug:   audio_calloc: 1 * 36
Debug:   es8388_init
Debug:   i2c_init
Info:    i2c port: 0
Info:    i2c sda: 17
Info:    i2c scl: 18
Debug:   void* i2c_bus_create(i2c_port_t, i2c_config_t*)
Info:    i2c clk_speed: 100000
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=25 value=4
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=1 value=80
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=2 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=53 value=160
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=55 value=208
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=57 value=208
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=8 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=192
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=0 value=18
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=24 value=2
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=38 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=39 value=144
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=42 value=144
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43 value=128
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=45 value=0
Debug:   es8388_set_adc_dac_volume: 0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=27 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=26 value=0
Info:    dac_output 2
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=60
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=255
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=9 value=187
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=10 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=11 value=2
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=13
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=13 value=2
Debug:   es8388_set_adc_dac_volume: 0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=16 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=17 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=9
Debug:   audio_codec_initialize -> 0
Info:    audio_codec_initialize-END-OK
Debug:   es8388_config_i2s
Debug:   es8388_config_fmt
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=8
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=16
Debug:   es8388_set_bits_per_sample
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
Debug:   es8388_set_voice_volume (HACK 2): 20
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=46 value=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=47 value=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=48 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=49 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=30 value=48
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=31 value=48
Debug:   setupI2S
Info:    i2s bck_io_num: 9
Info:    i2s ws_io_num: 45
Info:    i2s data_out_num: 10
Info:    i2s data_in_num: 8
Info:    i2s_set_pin
Info:    - bck_io_num: 9
Info:    - ws_io_num: 45
Info:    - data_out_num: 10
Info:    - data_in_num: 8
Info:    - mck_io_num: 16
Debug:   audio_hal_ctrl_codec
Info:    Codec mode is 2, Ctrl:1
Debug:   es8388_ctrl_state
Debug:   es8388_start
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43 value=128
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=60
Debug:   es8388_set_voice_mute
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=25
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=25 value=0
Debug:   es8388_start default is mode:2
Debug:   start default is decode mode:2
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024
Debug:   write: 1024

5 replies

pschatzmann Apr 2, 2023
Maintainer

Just did a quick test on the audiokit. I am getting this message but both input and output are working, so this is not the root cause of your issue!

I had a user who had issues and did not get any audio either. The final cause was no valid masterclock signal on gpio 0 because of some capacitors...

jay6621 Apr 2, 2023

Ok Thank you sir,
In that case I will probe on mclk if that is the cause.
I do not own a scope, So, I will test at my friend's place.

jay6621 Apr 11, 2023

I couldn't get to scope yet, meanwhile I tried changing mclk to GPIO0, getting same 0 as mic data.
I also tried using custom pins header file(as suggested in wiki) inside of Generic ES8388 board folder with no luck.
any ideas or help is much appreciated

pschatzmann Apr 11, 2023
Maintainer

Just looked at the instruction and the log output and they do not match at all!
I2S
Info: i2s_set_pin
Info: - bck_io_num: 9
Info: - ws_io_num: 45
Info: - data_out_num: 10
Info: - data_in_num: 8
Info: - mck_io_num: 16

ES8388 SCLK to ESP32-C3 GPIO 4 (=bck_io_num)
ES8388 LRCLK to ESP32-C3 GPIO 5 (=ws_io_num)
ES8388 DIN to ESP32-C3 GPIO 6 (data_in_num)
ES8388 DOUT to ESP32-C3 GPIO 7 (data_out_num)
ES8388 MCLK to ESP32-C3 GPIO 3 (mck_io_num)

I2C

Info: i2c sda: 17
Info: i2c scl: 18

ES8388 SCL to ESP32-C3 GPIO 8
ES8388 SDA to ESP32-C3 GPIO 9

jay6621 Apr 11, 2023

Yes Sir It is for ESP32-C3 , and I am using ESP32-S3 and There are audio boards like Korvo with same pins as mine using ESP32-S3 but with different codec.
PS I am using same PCB artist's ES8388 board as OP.

pschatzmann · 2023-04-11T07:45:18Z

pschatzmann
Apr 11, 2023
Maintainer

Just double check your wiring: in 95% of the cases that is the reason why it is not working.
For a further error analysis you will need a scope to check if you have valid signals on each pin

8 replies

jay6621 Apr 19, 2023

I do agree that pin number 16 is not working, with 0 as MCLK I get below output

starting AudioKit...
[D] AudioKit.h : 183 - audio_tools::AudioKitStreamConfig audio_tools::AudioKitStream::defaultConfig(audio_tools::RxTxMode)
[D] AudioKit.h : 191 - bool audio_tools::AudioKitStream::begin(audio_tools::AudioKitStreamConfig)
[D] AudioStError:   ->p_wire->endTransmission: 5
Error:   ->p_wire->endTransmission: 5
Error:   ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
Error:   ->p_wire->endTransmission: 5
Error:   ->p_wire->endTransmission: 2
AudioKit started
[D] AudioServer.h : 311 - void audio_tools::AudioEncoderServer::begin(Stream&, audio_tools::AudioInfo, audio_tools::BaseConverter<short int>*)
[D] AudioEncoded.h : 478 - void audio_tools::EncodedAudioStream::setStream(Stream*)
[D] AudioEncoded.h : 316 - virtual bool audio_tools::EncodedAudioPrint::begin()
[I] CodecWAV.h : 452 - sample_rate: 22050
[I] CodecWAV.h : 453 - channels: 2
[I] CodecWAV.h : 457 - is_streamed! because length is 2147418112
[D] AudioServer.h : 61 - void audio_tools::AudioServer::begin(Stream&, const char*)
[D] AudioServer.h : 171 - void audio_tools::AudioServer::connectWiFi()
..
IP address: 192.168.1.102
[I] AudioServer.h : 216 - New Client.
[D] AudioServer.h : 186 - virtual void audio_tools::AudioServer::sendReplyHeader()
[D] AudioServer.h : 355 - virtual void audio_tools::AudioEncoderServer::sendReplyContent()
[I] AudioServer.h : 368 - sendReply - Returning encoded stream...
[D] AudioEncoded.h : 316 - virtual bool audio_tools::EncodedAudioPrint::begin()
[I] CodecWAV.h : 452 - sample_rate: 22050
[I] CodecWAV.h : 453 - channels: 2
[I] CodecWAV.h : 457 - is_streamed! because length is 4294967295
[D] AudioStreams.h : 158 - audio_tools::AudioStreamWrapper::AudioStreamWrapper(Stream&)
[I] StreamCopy.h : 71 - buffer_size=1024
[D] AudioServer.h : 114 - copy data...
[D] StreamCopy.h : 92 - size_t audio_tools::StreamCopyT<T>::copy() [with T = unsigned char; size_t = unsigned int]
[D] AudioEncoded.h : 356 - EncodedAudioPrint::write: 1024
[I] CodecWAV.h : 501 - Writing Header
[I] StreamCopy.h : 136 - StreamCopy::copy 1024 -> 1024 -> 1024 bytes - in 1 hops
[D] AudioServer.h : 114 - copy data...
[D] StreamCopy.h : 92 - size_t audio_tools::StreamCopyT<T>::copy() [with T = unsigned char; size_t = unsigned int]
[D] AudioEncoded.h : 356 - EncodedAudioPrint::write: 1024
[I] StreamCopy.h : 136 - StreamCopy::copy 1024 -> 1024 -> 1024 bytes - in 1 hops
[D] AudioServer.h : 114 - copy data...

with less than 1 second lag.
I have to comment this line from Audiokit.h under AudioLibs folder in arduino-audio-tools library

  #ifdef ARDUINO
    if (!cfg.sd_active){
      LOGW("Deactivating SPI because SD is not active");
      SPI.end();     // I have to comment this line
    }
  #endif

I get 10 second around lag in mp3 server and aac server is not working at all.

pschatzmann Apr 19, 2023
Maintainer

I removed the SPI logic from the Audiokit.h
The lag is coming from your browser!
Not sure where the aac issue is coming from...

jay6621 Apr 20, 2023

With AAC I couldn't compile at all What I got is

streams-audiokit-webserver_aac:15:1: error: 'AACEncoderFDK' does not name a type
 AACEncoderFDK *fdk=nullptr;
 ^~~~~
D:\arduino-1.8.19\libraries\arduino-audio-tools\examples\examples-audiokit\streams-audiokit-webserver_aac\streams-audiokit-webserver_aac.ino: In function 'void setup()':
streams-audiokit-webserver_aac:27:3: error: 'fdk' was not declared in this scope
   fdk = new AACEncoderFDK();
   ^~~
streams-audiokit-webserver_aac:27:13: error: expected type-specifier before 'AACEncoderFDK'
   fdk = new AACEncoderFDK();
             ^~~~~

.
.
exit status 1
'AACEncoderFDK' does not name a type

I have arduino-libhelix installed.

pschatzmann Apr 20, 2023
Maintainer

But Helix is a decoder and can't do any encoding!
You will need to use https://github.com/pschatzmann/arduino-fdk-aac

jay6621 Apr 20, 2023

Sorry I mixed up those two, I have both installed.

pschatzmann · 2023-04-20T06:03:02Z

pschatzmann
Apr 20, 2023
Maintainer

I suggest that you read the Wiki about decoding and encoding!

1 reply

pschatzmann Apr 20, 2023
Maintainer

I updated the example yesterday and converted it to the actual conventions.
I suggest that you look at the updated example

However, yesterday I noticed that the examples does not work any more...

jay6621 · 2023-04-20T06:31:13Z

jay6621
Apr 20, 2023

Ok I got the latest example for webserver aac , It compiled but only getting noise as output,
with same Hardware setup Wav is working fine.
Updating the progress here.

0 replies

jay6621 · 2023-04-23T17:42:24Z

jay6621
Apr 23, 2023

I thought I should try some basics and gave input a try
with custom pins, board no. and log output level changed and got below result, I got all pins right,
I got setActive error and Couldn't figure out why.

Info:    bool audiokit::AudioKit::begin(audiokit::AudioKitConfig)
Info:    Selected board: 10
Info:    headphone detection: PA not supported
Debug:   audio_hal_init
Debug:   audio_calloc: 1 * 36
Debug:   es8388_init
Debug:   i2c_init
Info:    i2c port: 0
Info:    i2c sda: 17
Info:    i2c scl: 18
Debug:   void* i2c_bus_create(i2c_port_t, i2c_config_t*)
Info:    i2c clk_speed: 100000
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=25 value=4
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=1 value=80
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=2 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=53 value=160
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=55 value=208
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=57 value=208
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=8 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=192
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=0 value=18
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=24 value=2
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=38 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=39 value=144
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=42 value=144
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43 value=128
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=45 value=0
Debug:   es8388_set_adc_dac_volume: 0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=27 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=26 value=0
Info:    dac_output 2
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=60
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=255
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=9 value=187
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=10 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=11 value=2
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=13
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=13 value=2
Debug:   es8388_set_adc_dac_volume: 0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=16 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=17 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=9
Debug:   audio_codec_initialize -> 0
Info:    audio_codec_initialize-END-OK
Debug:   es8388_config_i2s
Debug:   es8388_config_fmt
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=8
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=16
Debug:   es8388_set_bits_per_sample
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=12
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
Debug:   es8388_set_voice_volume (HACK 1): 20
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=26 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=27 value=0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=46 value=6
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=47 value=6
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=48 value=6
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=49 value=6
Debug:   setupI2S
Info:    i2s bck_io_num: 9
Info:    i2s ws_io_num: 45
Info:    i2s data_out_num: 10
Info:    i2s data_in_num: 8
Info:    i2s_set_pin
Info:    - bck_io_num: 9
Info:    - ws_io_num: 45
Info:    - data_out_num: 10
Info:    - data_in_num: 8
Info:    - mck_io_num: 0
Debug:   audio_hal_ctrl_codec
Info:    Codec mode is 1, Ctrl:1
Debug:   es8388_ctrl_state
Debug:   es8388_start
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43 value=128
Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43
Error:   ->p_wire->requestFrom 1->0
Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=0
Error:   ->p_wire->endTransmission: 5
Debug:   es8388_start default is mode:1
Debug:   start default is decode mode:1
Error:   setActive
Debug:   read: 1024
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0
0, 0

0 replies

pschatzmann · 2023-04-23T18:04:28Z

pschatzmann
Apr 23, 2023
Maintainer

You obviously have some issues with I2C!
Maybe the wires are too long or you have some issues with insufficient pull ups.
You could try to decrease the I2C clock speed. Unfortunatly Espressif has hard coded this.
Search for master.clk_speed ...

0 replies

jay6621 · 2023-04-23T18:26:14Z

jay6621
Apr 23, 2023

Yes I do get your point but with exact same setup, streams-i2s-webserver_wav from es8388 library is working fine, It uses this library as setup as well. So my doubt is something is not getting configured right.

9 replies

jay6621 Apr 23, 2023

Tried Half speed with same result.

Hmm, you could try to change the config to use the orignal esp32 I2S api

you mean I2C right sir ? I tried both I2C with no luck

pschatzmann Apr 23, 2023
Maintainer

right:
# define AUDIOKIT_USE_WIRE 0

jay6621 Apr 23, 2023

Tried both at 100k and 50k getting same output

pschatzmann Apr 24, 2023
Maintainer

Just to confirm that the issue is not with my software, I was running a test on my AudioKit. Everything seems to be working there!

10:20:58.543 -> configsip: 0, SPIWP:0xee
10:20:58.543 -> clk_drv:0x00,q_drv:0x00,d_drv:0x00,cs0_drv:0x00,hd_drv:0x00,wp_drv:0x00
10:20:58.543 -> mode:DIO, clock div:1
10:20:58.543 -> load:0x3fff0030,len:1344
10:20:58.543 -> load:0x40078000,len:13924
10:20:58.543 -> ho 0 tail 12 room 4
10:20:58.543 -> load:0x40080400,len:3600
10:20:58.543 -> entry 0x400805f0
10:20:58.704 -> Info:    bool audiokit::AudioKit::begin(audiokit::AudioKitConfig)
10:20:58.704 -> Info:    Selected board: 5
10:20:58.704 -> Info:    headphone detection is active
10:20:58.704 -> Debug:   audio_hal_init
10:20:58.704 -> Debug:   audio_calloc: 1 * 36
10:20:58.704 -> Debug:   es8388_init
10:20:58.704 -> Debug:   i2c_init
10:20:58.704 -> Info:    i2c port: 0
10:20:58.704 -> Info:    i2c sda: 33
10:20:58.704 -> Info:    i2c scl: 32
10:20:58.704 -> Debug:   void* i2c_bus_create(i2c_port_t, i2c_config_t*)
10:20:58.704 -> Info:    i2c clk_speed: 100000
10:20:58.736 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=25 value=4
10:20:58.736 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=1 value=80
10:20:58.736 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=2 value=0
10:20:58.736 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=53 value=160
10:20:58.736 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=55 value=208
10:20:58.768 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=57 value=208
10:20:58.768 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=8 value=0
10:20:58.768 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=192
10:20:58.768 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=0 value=18
10:20:58.768 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
10:20:58.800 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=24 value=2
10:20:58.800 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=38 value=0
10:20:58.800 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=39 value=144
10:20:58.800 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=42 value=144
10:20:58.800 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43 value=128
10:20:58.832 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=45 value=0
10:20:58.832 -> Debug:   es8388_set_adc_dac_volume: 0
10:20:58.832 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=27 value=0
10:20:58.832 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=26 value=0
10:20:58.832 -> Info:    dac_output 2
10:20:58.832 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=4 value=60
10:20:58.864 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=255
10:20:58.864 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=9 value=187
10:20:58.864 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=10 value=80
10:20:58.864 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=11 value=2
10:20:58.864 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=13
10:20:58.896 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=13 value=2
10:20:58.896 -> Debug:   es8388_set_adc_dac_volume: 0
10:20:58.896 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=16 value=0
10:20:58.896 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=17 value=0
10:20:58.896 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=9
10:20:58.928 -> Debug:   audio_codec_initialize -> 0
10:20:58.928 -> Info:    audio_codec_initialize-END-OK
10:20:58.928 -> Debug:   es8388_config_i2s
10:20:58.928 -> Debug:   es8388_config_fmt
10:20:58.928 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12
10:20:58.928 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=12
10:20:58.928 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23
10:20:58.960 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
10:20:58.960 -> Debug:   es8388_set_bits_per_sample
10:20:58.960 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12
10:20:58.960 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=12 value=12
10:20:58.960 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23
10:20:58.960 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=23 value=24
10:20:58.992 -> Debug:   es8388_set_voice_volume (HACK 1): 20
10:20:58.992 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=26 value=0
10:20:58.992 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=27 value=0
10:20:58.992 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=46 value=6
10:20:58.992 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=47 value=6
10:20:59.025 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=48 value=6
10:20:59.025 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=49 value=6
10:20:59.025 -> Debug:   setupI2S
10:20:59.025 -> Info:    i2s_set_pin
10:20:59.025 -> Info:    - bck_io_num: 27
10:20:59.025 -> Info:    - ws_io_num: 25
10:20:59.025 -> Info:    - data_out_num: 26
10:20:59.025 -> Info:    - data_in_num: 35
10:20:59.025 -> Info:    - mck_io_num: 0
10:20:59.025 -> Debug:   audio_hal_ctrl_codec
10:20:59.025 -> Info:    Codec mode is 1, Ctrl:1
10:20:59.056 -> Debug:   es8388_ctrl_state
10:20:59.056 -> Debug:   es8388_start
10:20:59.056 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43
10:20:59.056 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43 value=128
10:20:59.056 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_read_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=43
10:20:59.056 -> Debug:   i2c_bus_write_bytes: addr=32 reglen=1 datalen=1 - reg=3 value=0
10:20:59.056 -> Debug:   es8388_start default is mode:1
10:20:59.088 -> Debug:   start default is decode mode:1
10:20:59.088 -> Debug:   read: 1024
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0
10:20:59.088 -> 0, 0

pschatzmann Apr 24, 2023
Maintainer

And looking at what's happening does not make a lot of sense to me: The reading of a register is failing. This is very strange since just 2 statements back, the same read was working fine!

jay6621 · 2023-07-08T18:14:23Z

jay6621
Jul 8, 2023

After updating to latest version, Audio server example (MP3) stopped working. It doesn't gave any error though but gives no audio. is it known issue ?
I can confirm that, These were working fine previously.
Hardware setup is same - ESP32S3 with ES8388 Module (By PCBArtists)

0 replies

pschatzmann · 2023-07-08T18:35:18Z

pschatzmann
Jul 8, 2023
Maintainer

I am not aware of any change which would cause this: I suggest that you double check your actual pins with the pins in the log. Maybe the masterclock is not correct?

In order to identify the breaking change you try to go back in the history and install up to the individual commits...

1 reply

jay6621 Jul 9, 2023

I don't know what is happening, I recently updated my Board Definitions for ESP32 at the same time I upgraded the Audio Kit Lib. to mix the mess even more I switched to Arduino version 2 too, So something is not working. I will update the state here.

Also I was wondering if there are any limitations on choosing Pins for I2S and I2C in Esp32s3 ?? Just asking for pcb routing.

jay6621 · 2023-07-27T20:06:29Z

jay6621
Jul 27, 2023

Update: I bought ESP32 Lyrat 4.3 board to get familiar with ES8388, Now, streams-url_mp3-audiokit is working fine but when I used streams-url_mp3_helix-i2s than No audio from speaker / headphone I got no errors on either.

0 replies

pschatzmann · 2023-07-27T20:27:33Z

pschatzmann
Jul 27, 2023
Maintainer

That's normal: just using I2S will not work if you don't set up the ES8388.
That's exactly what the AudioKitStream class is doing!

1 reply

jay6621 Jul 28, 2023

Ahaa.... I see.. Sorry my Bad.

jay6621 · 2023-07-30T06:34:00Z

jay6621
Jul 30, 2023

When I tried streams-audiokit-webserver_aac it only works when I define pins in sketch itself,

  auto config = kit.defaultConfig(RX_MODE);
  config.input_device = AUDIO_HAL_ADC_INPUT_LINE1;
  config.sample_rate = 44100; 
  config.default_actions_active = false; 
  config.channels = 2; 
  config.sd_active = false;
  config.pin_mck = 0;
  config.pin_bck = 5;
  config.pin_ws = 25;
  config.pin_data = 35;
  config.pin_data_rx = 26;
  kit.begin(config);

but streams-webserver_aac-audiokit works fine as it is without any modification.
I am using Lyrat 4.3 for testing now so No hardware issues.
Posting this just for info.

0 replies

ESP32-S3 with ES8388 #66

Replies: 18 comments · 31 replies

boondockadmin Feb 4, 2023 Author

pschatzmann Feb 5, 2023 Maintainer

boondockadmin Feb 5, 2023 Author

pschatzmann Feb 5, 2023 Maintainer

boondockadmin Feb 5, 2023 Author

boondockadmin Feb 5, 2023 Author

pschatzmann Apr 2, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 2, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 2, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 2, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 11, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 11, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 19, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 20, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 20, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 20, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 23, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 23, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 24, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 24, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Jul 8, 2023 Maintainer

pschatzmann Jul 27, 2023 Maintainer

Replies: 18 comments 31 replies

boondockadmin
Feb 4, 2023
Author

pschatzmann
Feb 5, 2023
Maintainer

boondockadmin Feb 5, 2023
Author

pschatzmann
Feb 5, 2023
Maintainer

boondockadmin Feb 5, 2023
Author

boondockadmin
Feb 5, 2023
Author

pschatzmann Apr 2, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann
Apr 2, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 2, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 2, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 11, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann
Apr 11, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 19, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 20, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann
Apr 20, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 20, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann
Apr 23, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 23, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 24, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann Apr 24, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann
Jul 8, 2023
Maintainer

pschatzmann
Jul 27, 2023
Maintainer