You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Study the performance of redrock on cosmics-masked coadds. On a low-statistics cross check of ELG tile 80608 on night 20201216, the results weren't convincing that cosmics masking/coadds were helping.
Comparing redrock fits on spectra (without cosmics masking) vs. desi_coadd_spectra --nsig 4 coadds with cosmics masking, 63 differed by more than 300 km/s. However, only 4 of those were in the truth table /global/cfs/cdirs/desi/sv/vi/TruthTables/Blanc/ELG/desi-vi_ELG_tile80608_nightdeep_merged_all_210208.csv with best_quality>2.5. Of those 4:
TARGETID Z
39633321168212037 1.0433 orig correct, cosmics-masked coadd changed to 0.78, both with ZWARN=4
39633334912946761 1.6321 orig wrong, cosmics-masked coadd correct, both with ZWARN=4
39633338322913292 1.629 both incorrect, but cosmics-masked coadd incorrectly confident ZWARN=0
39633341661577371 2.371 orig correct, cosmics-masked coadd changed to 1.37, both with ZWARN=4
i.e. it's only 4 targets and all of them had ZWARN=4 in the orig spectra, but 3 out of 4 cases the orig non-cosmics masked version was more correct. There might be some confirmation bias in the truth table since it was also vetted on an earlier non-cosmics masked version of these spectra.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Study the performance of redrock on cosmics-masked coadds. On a low-statistics cross check of ELG tile 80608 on night 20201216, the results weren't convincing that cosmics masking/coadds were helping.
Comparing redrock fits on spectra (without cosmics masking) vs.
desi_coadd_spectra --nsig 4
coadds with cosmics masking, 63 differed by more than 300 km/s. However, only 4 of those were in the truth table /global/cfs/cdirs/desi/sv/vi/TruthTables/Blanc/ELG/desi-vi_ELG_tile80608_nightdeep_merged_all_210208.csv with best_quality>2.5. Of those 4:i.e. it's only 4 targets and all of them had ZWARN=4 in the orig spectra, but 3 out of 4 cases the orig non-cosmics masked version was more correct. There might be some confirmation bias in the truth table since it was also vetted on an earlier non-cosmics masked version of these spectra.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: