SIRI-SX, Attribute "Name" on ActionData

[TuThoThai]

Context: France is currently updating its profile of SIRI with a special focus on SIRI-SX

What we have found:

• In the XSD, the description of the Structure for ActionData includes 3 attributes that are mandatory (Name, Type, Value)
• Systems tend to use more Type and Prompt as described below

<siri:PtSituationElement>
  <siri:PublishingActions>
    <siri:PublishToWebAction>
      <!-- ... -->
      <siri:ActionData>
        <siri:Name>often empty</siri:Name>

        <siri:Type>short</siri:Type>
        <siri:Value>uncertain of what to put here</siri:Value>

        <siri:Prompt xml:lang="EN">The train will change rolling stock at Dovre. You will have to change trains at this station.</siri:Prompt>

      </siri:ActionData>
    </siri:PublishToWebAction>
  </siri:PublishingActions>
</siri:PtSituationElement>

Question: would it make sense to have the cardinality of Name changed to 0:1 instead of 1:1, to avoid having this field required but always empty?

If you think it would make sense, I am happy to prepare the PR.

[Aurige]

I agree with this, of course. I guess that the Value (which is an xsd:any) should not be mandatory either.
We could also take the opportunity of updating ActionData to add an ActionCode to uniquely identify the action in order to ease its tracking on data consumer side.

[TuThoThai]

Thanks for your prompt feedback on this matter @Aurige. I will work on the PR shortly!