You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
It was failing in the model so I removed it with the intention of fixing the model at some point, but never got back to it.
There is weak supplementation only for temporal regions.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Each of the extant weak-supplementation axioms, vbw-1 and fyf-1, has a (instance-of _ temporal-region _) clause in the antecedent that I think is unnecessary. For example take fyf-1; I've boldfaced the clause I have in mind:
(cl:comment "continuant-part-of has weak supplementation [fyf-1]"
(forall (t x y)
(if
(and (instance-of x continuant t) (instance-of y continuant t) (instance-of t temporal-region t))
(if (and (continuant-part-of x y t) (not (= x y)))
(exists (z)
(and (instance-of z continuant t) (continuant-part-of z y t)
(not (= z y))
(not
(exists (overlap)
(and (instance-of overlap continuant t)
(continuant-part-of overlap x t)
(continuant-part-of overlap z t))))))))))
What of importance would be lost if the boldfaced clause and the analogous one in vbw-1 were deleted and any consequently necessary adjustments were made? (With this one I think you can just delete the clause and that's that (haven't checked) but with the other one I think a quantified variable needs to be deleted.)
Another seemingly deletable clause in boldface; another clause in italics for reasons stated below:
(cl:comment "continuant-part-of has weak supplementation [fyf-1]"
(forall (t x y)
(if
(and (instance-of x continuant t) (instance-of y continuant t)
(instance-of t temporal-region t))
(if (and (continuant-part-of x y t) (not (= x y)))
(exists (z)
(and (instance-of z continuant t)(continuant-part-of z y t)
(not (= z y))
(not
(exists (overlap)
(and (instance-of overlap continuant t)
(continuant-part-of overlap x t)
(continuant-part-of overlap z t))))))))))
The boldfaced clause is entailed by the italicized one.
It was failing in the model so I removed it with the intention of fixing the model at some point, but never got back to it.
There is weak supplementation only for temporal regions.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: